Quote:
Originally Posted by Jaxbuck
James' ideal isn't a conga line around the bases by a bunch of all walk no hit guys. He, just like I said above, says the ideal is a lineup full of guys who can do both but if you have to pick a side to favor toward pick the OBP side.
|
Like I said, my comments weren't directed at you. It just seems some that spout off the OBP arguments act as if that is the only important factor. I think the biggest contribution of James' theories (that anyone has yet to truly apply) is the idea of getting away from "roles" in the lineup. You simply put your best guys at the top. That's why if Bruce rips it up in ST, I'd put him in the lead off spot. If he's anywhere near as good as advertised, he'll be far more productive than Hopper or Freel. I also advocated Hamilton at the top of the order last season for the same reason.
I'd personally like to see a lineup of:
Bruce
Phillips
Griffey
Dunn
Edwin
Votto
Gonzalez/Keppinger
Ross/Nacho Libre
I would even think of sliding Votto up into the #2 hole if he continues to mash. I'd prefer to see Griffey slide down to 5, but we all know that won't happen with Dusty.