View Single Post
  #18 (permalink)  
Old 09-07-2008, 08:21 PM
TheIronColonel's Avatar
TheIronColonel TheIronColonel is offline
Hall of Fame
 
BP Donor
Join Date: Mar 2008
Posts: 1,219
Points: 4,060,602.86
Bank: 0.00
Total Points: 4,060,602.86
TheIronColonel is a revered BP posterTheIronColonel is a revered BP posterTheIronColonel is a revered BP posterTheIronColonel is a revered BP posterTheIronColonel is a revered BP posterTheIronColonel is a revered BP posterTheIronColonel is a revered BP posterTheIronColonel is a revered BP posterTheIronColonel is a revered BP posterTheIronColonel is a revered BP poster
TheIronColonel is a revered BP posterTheIronColonel is a revered BP posterTheIronColonel is a revered BP posterTheIronColonel is a revered BP posterTheIronColonel is a revered BP posterTheIronColonel is a revered BP posterTheIronColonel is a revered BP posterTheIronColonel is a revered BP posterTheIronColonel is a revered BP posterTheIronColonel is a revered BP posterTheIronColonel is a revered BP posterTheIronColonel is a revered BP posterTheIronColonel is a revered BP posterTheIronColonel is a revered BP posterTheIronColonel is a revered BP posterTheIronColonel is a revered BP posterTheIronColonel is a revered BP posterTheIronColonel is a revered BP posterTheIronColonel is a revered BP posterTheIronColonel is a revered BP posterTheIronColonel is a revered BP poster
Quote:
Originally Posted by Jake View Post
I guess it depends on how one looks at the poll. I don't see it as making a prediction each week, so whether or not I think a team could go unbeaten is irrelevant to me in September.

I see filling out a poll as an assessment of where teams are THAT week. That's why LSU is still #1 in my poll. They're undefeated since they won the title game. If/when they lose, I'll drop them.
I'm not convinced that's a good way to rank teams, though. While it's true that LSU has won their last three games, one of them was last year. I'd rather rank teams based on some combination of what they've done this year and what I expect them to do this year.

Don't get me wrong, I wouldn't rank ECU highly because I think they can go unbeaten. The only reason I'd rank them highly right now is because they've beaten two top ten teams so far (yeah, VT isn't as good as advertised, but still). That's way more than any other team can claim up to this point.
Reply With Quote
 
Page generated in 0.12298 seconds with 9 queries