Quote:
Originally Posted by LitlBuck
I guess what I am asking and it hasn't been answered is if everyone is satisfied with keeping Garko at first base next season. I know that his value is lower right now than Shopach's but if everyone is happy with Garko at first base then trade Shopach. I also do not think you can judge a player by past performance because every once in awhile the light does go on for a player.
|
i'm fairly sure i made my feelings about garko known already.
garko is adequate at 1st only if you get 2004-2006 Hafner, a healthy V-Mart, and something that isn't 2005 Peralta. if you think september garko is what you'll get for a whole season, then he's fine. otherwise, cleveland needs more power production from that position.
But if Shoppach is the key to a trade that gets Cleveland a 3rd baseman or a FOR starter, there's no way you can't pull the trigger.