'06 OH OL/DL Billy Nagy (Wisconsin signee)

[gobucks19]

Originally Posted by MililaniBuckeye

I wonder who the other two (aside from Smith) of the three are. Ballard is being brought in as a TE, so he shouldn't count as one of the three, I would think. Seeing as Wisconsin has offered, you'd figure our staff would be looking at him more...

I am hearing they feel confident with Brown but they wont know for sure until at least after the Texas game and most likely later in Sept or early Oct after his other visits. I dont think they are waiting on him, maybe they are waiting on seeing the other guys early in the year.

Maybe Palmer and Browing? who else is left? I think they slim-to-no chance at the OOS guys at this point - Walton and the kid from GA. I think those are the only two that even listed tOSU.

I can see these OH OL waiting on an offer from tOSU for awhile as it sounds like they all really want to be Buckeyes. This reminds of what the FL schools do every year. Offer the big dogs first and wait them out, then come in a clean up in-state with the Tier2 guys who are dying for an offer.

[tsteele316]

Originally Posted by gobucks19

I am hearing they feel confident with Brown but they wont know for sure until at least after the Texas game and most likely later in Sept or early Oct after his other visits. I dont think they are waiting on him, maybe they are waiting on seeing the other guys early in the year.

Maybe Palmer and Browing? who else is left? I think they slim-to-no chance at the OOS guys at this point - Walton and the kid from GA. I think those are the only two that even listed tOSU.

I can see these OH OL waiting on an offer from tOSU for awhile as it sounds like they all really want to be Buckeyes. This reminds of what the FL schools do every year. Offer the big dogs first and wait them out, then come in a clean up in-state with the Tier2 guys who are dying for an offer.

the latest palmer update on rivals has bollman quoted as saying osu will take 3 maybe 4 OL this year. what that means for offers to in-state guys i'm not sure. if brown comes aboard osu has one guard and one tackle. my guess is there won't be any offers issued until brown commits.

[wadc45]

Originally Posted by tsteele316

the latest palmer update on rivals has bollman quoted as saying osu will take 3 maybe 4 OL this year. what that means for offers to in-state guys i'm not sure. if brown comes aboard osu has one guard and one tackle. my guess is there won't be any offers issued until brown commits.

I agree...Brown is the key right now. I think Nagy might be the first to see an offer after Brown decides, with Browning and Palmer not far behind. I think Nagy is physically the most ready to contribute. He is a bit bigger, stronger and faster than Palmer. And Browning is big and somewhat strong but he is going to have to shed a few pounds and improve his speed/quickness. Jackson is in the same boat.

Neither Palmer nor Browning nor Jackson had very impressive SPARQ scores. Rivals does not list a score for Nagy.

[gobucks19]

Originally Posted by tsteele316

the latest palmer update on rivals has bollman quoted as saying osu will take 3 maybe 4 OL this year. what that means for offers to in-state guys i'm not sure. if brown comes aboard osu has one guard and one tackle. my guess is there won't be any offers issued until brown commits.

with the depth in this years class and the extra 3 schollies, I would think they would take 4.

I dont see any of the OOS guys coming here: JB Walton [MD], Sam Young [FL] or Antonio Logan-El [MD], but I could be wrong. I havent seen an update on Young in months and we werent listed anyway. Walton seems enamoured with Tenn, the southern schools and I am not sure if his grades are right. Logan-El reopened his recuritment from Maryland but didnt list us.

Who are the other 2 besides Nagy that the staff is looking at for the final 1 or 2 spots? I assume it to be Palmer and Browning but maybe they are waiting on a few surprises to perform well during the first part of the season before extending any further offers. With Smith and Brown [assumption], they can afford to wait. Most schools would be happy to have either one of them, let alone both.

[OSUBucks22]

in his chat the other day Duane Long was very confident that Browning was going to get an offer. he said that he would offer all three (Browning, Nagy, and Palmer). he also said he's very confident that Aaron Brown comes aboard. he said he then thought that it would be Browning, Palmer, and Nagy in that order for offers. so maybe the four we take are Smith, Brown, Browning, and Palmer. i think Nagy's versatility would put him up there, but maybe what the coach told stow about being third on the waiting list was right... it would make sense with what Duane said.

[wadc45]

Originally Posted by OSUBucks22

in his chat the other day Duane Long was very confident that Browning was going to get an offer. he said that he would offer all three (Browning, Nagy, and Palmer). he also said he's very confident that Aaron Brown comes aboard. he said he then thought that it would be Browning, Palmer, and Nagy in that order for offers. so maybe the four we take are Smith, Brown, Browning, and Palmer. i think Nagy's versatility would put him up there, but maybe what the coach told stow about being third on the waiting list was right... it would make sense with what Duane said.

having seen video of all three, there is no way I would put Nagy third, and I was surprised to here Duane Long say that considering he had Palmer rated 14th in Ohio, Nagy 15th and Browning 30th. Rivals has Browning 15th, Nagy 27th Palmer 37th. I know ranking don't me squat but I think the Glenville bias is creeping into the situation a bit here. Obviously either Duane needs to go back to the Ohio High people and adjust his rankings or he rated Nagy based on the potential of OSU taking him as a DT. I think Nagy is the best of the three based on talent, size and versatility...

[gobucks19]

Originally Posted by wadc45

having seen video of all three, there is no way I would put Nagy third, and I was surprised to here Duane Long say that considering he had Palmer rated 14th in Ohio, Nagy 15th and Browning 30th. Rivals has Browning 15th, Nagy 27th Palmer 37th. I know ranking don't me squat but I think the Glenville bias is creeping into the situation a bit here. Obviously either Duane needs to go back to the Ohio High people and adjust his rankings or he rated Nagy based on the potential of OSU taking him as a DT. I think Nagy is the best of the three based on talent, size and versatility...

I agree with this statement today but its all about projecting to the next level. Maybe the staff feels that Nagy is near his peak in terms of ability and Palmer/Browning are well below. Palmer is the wildcard one, I think the reason he is at or near the top of the list for the next offer is because of his size and potential. 6-7" guys with a frame to add 30-40 lbs dont grow on trees. I agree his speed is suspect but when do these OL actually run 40 yards.

I personally would offer all 3 because of Nagy's versatility to slide across to DT in a class that is weak at that position. Maybe they are waiting on word from some of the DT prospects to offer Nagy. Thats 5 OL assuming everyone commits with a chance for only 4 if Nagy ends up at DT. Thats a good number for this class.

[tsteele316]

Originally Posted by gobucks19

I agree with this statement today but its all about projecting to the next level. Maybe the staff feels that Nagy is near his peak in terms of ability and Palmer/Browning are well below. Palmer is the wildcard one, I think the reason he is at or near the top of the list for the next offer is because of his size and potential. 6-7" guys with a frame to add 30-40 lbs dont grow on trees. I agree his speed is suspect but when do these OL actually run 40 yards.

I personally would offer all 3 because of Nagy's versatility to slide across to DT in a class that is weak at that position. Maybe they are waiting on word from some of the DT prospects to offer Nagy. Thats 5 OL assuming everyone commits with a chance for only 4 if Nagy ends up at DT. Thats a good number for this class.

i guess it will all depend on whether or not the staff thinks that they need more help at guard or at tackle. perhaps ideally, the staff wants two of each. smith and brown give osu one of each. palmer certainly is the only tackle candidate of the three. following this line of thinking, it depends on whether the staff feels browning or nagy is the better choice at guard. the one good thing is that the staff has time to wait as none of these kids seem to be in an immediate hurry to make a choice.

[OSUBasketballJunkie]

Obviously either Duane needs to go back to the Ohio High people and adjust his rankings or he rated Nagy based on the potential of OSU taking him as a DT

If Nagy gets an offer and verbals to OSU, I see him playing DT at OSU. If you take a look at our depth chart the next couple of years we need some depth on the defensive line and this is not a great year in Ohio for D lineman or for guys nationally looking at OSU.

[tsteele316]

Originally Posted by bucknuts44820

If Nagy gets an offer and verbals to OSU, I see him playing DT at OSU. If you take a look at our depth chart the next couple of years we need some depth on the defensive line and this is not a great year in Ohio for D lineman or for guys nationally looking at OSU.

i really think rob rose or one of the DE's recruited last year moves inside to play DT.

i say that because of the following:

you are correct about osu's depth chart at DT over the next few years. osu took one DT last year, and 3 DE's. looking at osu's offer set thus far this year, osu has offered a handful of DT's (with no real strong chances at any as of now), and quite a few DE's again. osu is in good shape with rose and dublin. if they would both commit, that would equate to taking 5 DE's and one DT over the past two recruiting seasons, especially after only taking one DT in '04. That's why I think somebody is moving inside. But that scenario could also pave the way for Nagy getting a late DT offer.

[wadc45]

Originally Posted by tsteele316

i really think rob rose or one of the DE's recruited last year moves inside to play DT.

i say that because of the following:

you are correct about osu's depth chart at DT over the next few years. osu took one DT last year, and 3 DE's. looking at osu's offer set thus far this year, osu has offered a handful of DT's (with no real strong chances at any as of now), and quite a few DE's again. osu is in good shape with rose and dublin. if they would both commit, that would equate to taking 5 DE's and one DT over the past two recruiting seasons, especially after only taking one DT in '04. That's why I think somebody is moving inside. But that scenario could also pave the way for Nagy getting a late DT offer.

I think Wilson, Gholston and Williams is your future rotation at DE. If anyone slides down from last year, it's Worthington. He has the size to get a whole lot heavier. Alex Barrow will also be in the mix at DE. That means that the DT situation probably includes Cotton, Abdallah, Denlinger, possibly Worthington, and I suspect Robert Rose moves down to DT. If Dekle gets his grades in order, he could be a hot commodity given the lack of depth at DT. If not, I think Nagy gets an offer as a DT for sure. Either Nagy or Dekle would at least give the staff a little flexibility with where they want to use Rose...

[OSUBasketballJunkie]

rivals.com$

8/11/05

Nagy will visit Wisconsin on Dec 5 and Syracuse on Dec 12. He wants to take his five visits and then decide. The OSU staff has been staying in touch. Nagy grew up as a Ohio State fan.

[osugrad21]

Cleveland.com

8/12

No rush:

Hudson two-way tackle Billy Nagy has decided to wait until after the season to make his college choice.

Nagy, 6-4, 298 pounds, said he will make official visits to Wisconsin and Syracuse in December, but still is interested in Louisville, Illinois, Indiana, Maryland, Vanderbilt, Boston College and Ohio State.

- Tim Rogers

[wadc45]

I still think Nagy is the next lineman to get offered. I know a lot of people like Browning and Palmer, but Nagy's versatility makes him such a Tressel-type recruit. Browning has to prove that he can get his weight down and keep it there, and Palmer needs to prove that he is quick enough to play anywhere on the line. Nagy could play guard, tackle or flip over to defensive tackle. That's why I think he gets the next offer...

[Taosman]

I think your right , Wad!