Quote:
Originally Posted by LordJeffBuck
Eh, maybe I've been spoiled with MoC and Beanie these past few years, but I just don't see "it" with Herron. It looks like he's running hard and making pretty good reads (unlike Saine), but Herron just can't seem to turn the 3-yard runs into 7-yard runs, which is what separates the good backs from the great backs ... and keeps offenses in 2nd-and short instead of 2nd-and-long. Beanie has great power and is surprisingly nimble and very fast for a man his size ... and MoC had unreal vision and timing to go along with great leg drive and body lean ... and he had moves that could make DB's look positively silly in the open field. But what quality does Herron have that takes him to the next level?
Herron is a poor man's Pittman ... and Pittman wasn't all that great ... he was the beneficiary of a very potent offense that had two great individual playmakers (Smith, Ginn) that kept defenses very honest ... not to mention a really solid offensive line.
Was Ohio State a great tailabck away from a national championship in 1996 (Pepe Pearson) and 1998 (Michael Wiley)? I'd sure hate to see the Buckeyes in that position again in 2009 and 2010 with Herron and/or Saine....
|
OK. Slow down here. Herron will turn out to be a very good, if not a great, running back. He has the potential to put on another 10 -15 lbs of muscle and get to be a big bruising back with speed, ala Beanie.
Remember, Beanie did not come in and unseat Pittman for the starting job his freshman year because he had a case of the dropsies, as well as poor field vision.
Herron is getting better every time he plays. His field vision is improving which is apparant since there were a couple of his runs where he saw a seam AFTER hesitating just enough and exploded through it. This did not happen a couple of weeks ago when he seemed to take the hand off and run right into the back of the OL and got stoned at the LOS.
I guess what I am saying here is that we fans need to step back from making these rash generalizations of young players whom we have seen play only a handful of times. If you were talking about Mo Wells, then I would agree in what you are saying as he is a senior and we have seen him play over the course of 4 years. But, with a kid who really has only played 4 1/2 games (YSU he only carried 5 times, that is the 1/2) you really should hold judgement on his ability until he gets a little more coaching and experience.