Good topic. I agree with making it college career only.
I actually agree with Doss (3-time All-American) over Carter (which could have flipped to Carter if he had played 1 more year).
But I prefer Corny Greene over Joe Germaine for the #7. Greene won that Big-10 MVP in 1975, the year that Archie won the second Heisman. He also led the undefeated team in 1973, which only had the 10-10 tie in AA (in the game where he couldn't throw a pass because of a fractured thumb).
The #10 is a close call between Schlichter and Kern. Hopefully Troy Smith can end that debate this year.
