A little cognitive dissonance, BKB and Yertle?
I wouldn't discount an eyewitness report offhand, just because it didn't sound as positive as expected. Heck if these same two grammatically challenged

BPers had given a negative report on a prized scUM recruit, would we doubt them then?
But on the other hand, if our staff sees fit to offer Mobley a schollie, then I will give that the most merit by far. Maybe his HS coaches just don't know how to utilize his skills - don't know, I didn't see the game like Butcher and Hollywood did.