I've started/kept a pretty consistent tradition in this regard on a season by season basis since I started at
OSU last year
Last year wore the Scarlet (old sleeves) Ted Ginn Jersey for every home game, the White (old sleeves) Troy Smith jersey for every away game
This year I wore a Scarlet (New sleeves obviously) Beanie Wells Jersey for every home game, and the Scarlet (old sleeves) Ted Ginn jersey for every away game.
The only 2 times I've broken the tradition, easy to guess, last year bought a white Troy Smith national championship jersey to wear for the Florida game, and wore the Scarlet Ginn jersey for the home game against the Illini this year because the games were in back to back weeks and I didn't remember to get Beanie through the laundry.
Since I'm going to the game and we're wearing the home scarlets I've decided the Beanie jersey is the best choice, along with atleast 4 Buckeye necklaces, and my "Beat Michigan" wristbands gray on left wrist, scarlet on right