BuckeyePlanet Ohio State Forums  

Go Back   BuckeyePlanet Ohio State Forums > Football > Buckeye Football > College Football

College Football The place to talk about college football teams other than Ohio State

 
Reply
 
LinkBack Thread Tools Display Modes
  #16 (permalink)  
Old 07-29-2005, 10:47 PM
osugrad21's Avatar
Capo Regime
Administrator
 
BP Donor




Join Date: Feb 2004
Posts: 38,777
Points: 13,520,008.12
Bank: 0.00
Total Points: 13,520,008.12
osugrad21 is a legend of The 'Shoeosugrad21 is a legend of The 'Shoeosugrad21 is a legend of The 'Shoeosugrad21 is a legend of The 'Shoeosugrad21 is a legend of The 'Shoeosugrad21 is a legend of The 'Shoeosugrad21 is a legend of The 'Shoeosugrad21 is a legend of The 'Shoeosugrad21 is a legend of The 'Shoeosugrad21 is a legend of The 'Shoeosugrad21 is a legend of The 'Shoeosugrad21 is a legend of The 'Shoeosugrad21 is a legend of The 'Shoeosugrad21 is a legend of The 'Shoeosugrad21 is a legend of The 'Shoeosugrad21 is a legend of The 'Shoeosugrad21 is a legend of The 'Shoeosugrad21 is a legend of The 'Shoeosugrad21 is a legend of The 'Shoeosugrad21 is a legend of The 'Shoeosugrad21 is a legend of The 'Shoeosugrad21 is a legend of The 'Shoeosugrad21 is a legend of The 'Shoeosugrad21 is a legend of The 'Shoeosugrad21 is a legend of The 'Shoe
osugrad21 is a legend of The 'Shoeosugrad21 is a legend of The 'Shoeosugrad21 is a legend of The 'Shoeosugrad21 is a legend of The 'Shoeosugrad21 is a legend of The 'Shoeosugrad21 is a legend of The 'Shoeosugrad21 is a legend of The 'Shoeosugrad21 is a legend of The 'Shoeosugrad21 is a legend of The 'Shoeosugrad21 is a legend of The 'Shoeosugrad21 is a legend of The 'Shoeosugrad21 is a legend of The 'Shoeosugrad21 is a legend of The 'Shoeosugrad21 is a legend of The 'Shoeosugrad21 is a legend of The 'Shoeosugrad21 is a legend of The 'Shoeosugrad21 is a legend of The 'Shoeosugrad21 is a legend of The 'Shoeosugrad21 is a legend of The 'Shoeosugrad21 is a legend of The 'Shoeosugrad21 is a legend of The 'Shoeosugrad21 is a legend of The 'Shoeosugrad21 is a legend of The 'Shoeosugrad21 is a legend of The 'Shoeosugrad21 is a legend of The 'Shoe
Quote:
Originally Posted by coastalbuck
Was it Usher's that was removed? I know a little about that situation. ???
He was put under review, but according to his father, was transferring to your campus anyway. His father was leading the charge in Greenville though...
__________________
Oderint dum metuant.
Digg this Post!Add Post to del.icio.usBookmark Post in TechnoratiFurl this Post!Stumble it!Reddit! Share on Facebook!Google bookmark it!Wong this Post!
Reply With Quote
Sponsored Links
  #17 (permalink)  
Old 07-30-2005, 10:56 AM
Senior
 

Join Date: Apr 2004
Posts: 123
Points: 2,017.10
Bank: 0.00
Total Points: 2,017.10
chuck_jax is a Buckeye prospectchuck_jax is a Buckeye prospectchuck_jax is a Buckeye prospectchuck_jax is a Buckeye prospectchuck_jax is a Buckeye prospect
Ammo against Spurrier

Don't think for a second that kids considering South Carolina won't get an earful from other head coaches about what happened, and for a long time to come.

Has Spurrier ever pulled a schollie from one of his own picks?
Digg this Post!Add Post to del.icio.usBookmark Post in TechnoratiFurl this Post!Stumble it!Reddit! Share on Facebook!Google bookmark it!Wong this Post!
Reply With Quote
  #18 (permalink)  
Old 07-30-2005, 11:25 AM
ohiobuck94's Avatar
Buckeye Beach Bum
 

Join Date: Jun 2003
Posts: 1,288
Points: 23,318.50
Bank: 0.00
Total Points: 23,318.50
ohiobuck94 is a redshirtohiobuck94 is a redshirtohiobuck94 is a redshirtohiobuck94 is a redshirtohiobuck94 is a redshirtohiobuck94 is a redshirtohiobuck94 is a redshirtohiobuck94 is a redshirtohiobuck94 is a redshirtohiobuck94 is a redshirtohiobuck94 is a redshirtohiobuck94 is a redshirt
He did a great job with the Washington Redskins. They kicked him to the curb.
He can't handle men so he picks on the kids.
Digg this Post!Add Post to del.icio.usBookmark Post in TechnoratiFurl this Post!Stumble it!Reddit! Share on Facebook!Google bookmark it!Wong this Post!
Reply With Quote
  #19 (permalink)  
Old 07-30-2005, 05:45 PM
BB73's Avatar
Loves Buckeye History
Senior Moderator
 
BP Donor



Chicago Cubs Chicago Bulls Chicago Bears

Join Date: Apr 2004
Location: Outside Chicago
Posts: 26,289
Points: 1,501,645,259.55
Bank: 0.00
Total Points: 1,501,645,259.55
BB73 is a legend of The 'ShoeBB73 is a legend of The 'ShoeBB73 is a legend of The 'ShoeBB73 is a legend of The 'ShoeBB73 is a legend of The 'ShoeBB73 is a legend of The 'ShoeBB73 is a legend of The 'ShoeBB73 is a legend of The 'ShoeBB73 is a legend of The 'ShoeBB73 is a legend of The 'ShoeBB73 is a legend of The 'ShoeBB73 is a legend of The 'ShoeBB73 is a legend of The 'ShoeBB73 is a legend of The 'ShoeBB73 is a legend of The 'ShoeBB73 is a legend of The 'ShoeBB73 is a legend of The 'ShoeBB73 is a legend of The 'ShoeBB73 is a legend of The 'ShoeBB73 is a legend of The 'ShoeBB73 is a legend of The 'ShoeBB73 is a legend of The 'ShoeBB73 is a legend of The 'ShoeBB73 is a legend of The 'ShoeBB73 is a legend of The 'Shoe
BB73 is a legend of The 'ShoeBB73 is a legend of The 'ShoeBB73 is a legend of The 'ShoeBB73 is a legend of The 'ShoeBB73 is a legend of The 'ShoeBB73 is a legend of The 'ShoeBB73 is a legend of The 'ShoeBB73 is a legend of The 'ShoeBB73 is a legend of The 'ShoeBB73 is a legend of The 'ShoeBB73 is a legend of The 'ShoeBB73 is a legend of The 'ShoeBB73 is a legend of The 'ShoeBB73 is a legend of The 'ShoeBB73 is a legend of The 'ShoeBB73 is a legend of The 'ShoeBB73 is a legend of The 'ShoeBB73 is a legend of The 'ShoeBB73 is a legend of The 'ShoeBB73 is a legend of The 'ShoeBB73 is a legend of The 'ShoeBB73 is a legend of The 'ShoeBB73 is a legend of The 'ShoeBB73 is a legend of The 'ShoeBB73 is a legend of The 'Shoe
Here's an article discussing Spurrier's reaction to the flap about the schollies.

si.com

Explaining himself
Spurrier writes to coaches after revoking scholarships



Steve Spurrier wrote to six South Carolina players, telling them their scholarships would not be renewed.

COLUMBIA, S.C. (AP) -- South Carolina coach Steve Spurrier explained his reasons for revoking scholarships in a letter to state high school football head coaches after the South Carolina Football Coaches Association's Board of Directors called Spurrier's move "unethical."

Spurrier said Saturday he wrote the letter because he wanted the state's high school coaches to understand his actions.

He's gotten several calls of support from prep coaches since the board's letter came out Wednesday. As far as the 90 or so coaches who signed it, Spurrier said, "I'll tell you something I learned a long time ago, everybody doesn't like me and everybody doesn't like South Carolina. If they can find something to blast us and talk negatively about us, they'll do it. So my message to the Carolina fan is don't listen to the enemy talk about us."

Earlier this summer, Spurrier wrote to six players that their scholarships, which are awarded yearly, would not be renewed. Spurrier also added that of those six, three players remained with the Gamecocks and at least one could have his scholarship renewed by next week.

Two others -- reported to be defensive back Trent Usher and offensive lineman Josh Winchell -- are expected to transfer. Receiver Grayson Mullins is the third known player to have his scholarship pulled.

Spurrier would not reveal the three players sent letters who remained working with the Gamecocks.

The board's letter, also sent to South Carolina athletic director Eric Hyman, said it felt that "USC has shown a lack of commitment to numerous athletes by threatening to revoke and revoking scholarships to athletes who are meeting all the requirements established by your football program."

The group went on to say that taking away a "scholarship because you feel an athlete cannot play at the level needed to compete in the Southeastern Conference is unethical."

Spurrier has said several times that he wanted to reward those players most deserving with scholarships. There are walk-ons, he said, who bring more to the program than some recruited players and should be rewarded. Spurrier recently gave two walk-ons, receiver Michael Flint and long-snapper Ike Crofoot, scholarships. He said there are other walk-ons who also may fit into South Carolina's maximum limit of 85 scholarships.

He said Saturday he didn't feel he'd done anything wrong. The NCAA says players must be told of their yearly scholarship renewals by July 1.

Spurrier's letter to coaches laid out how South Carolina's number of players grew to what it did and how the coaches chose to resolve it.

Spurrier admitted this was a rare situation. "We've never been squeezed numbers-wise the way we were here," he said.

Andy Tweito, a Daniel High assistant who is a member of the SCFCA board, said earlier this week that the coaches were not trying to start a battle with Spurrier. "We felt we had to say something," he said.

Tweito had said that some coaches at the meeting said they might not let South Carolina recruiters on their schools.

The SCFCA letter also asked the South Carolina High School League to consider pulling its five state championship games from Williams-Brice Stadium in December. The league's Weekend of Champions has been held at South Carolina's stadium each fall since 1997.

Was this the first time Spurrier's ever been labeled unethical? "Oh sure," he says, "every time we score over 50, they said I'd run it up, or put the backups in the game and keep scoring."

Spurrier says he'll give the matter as much credence as it deserves. "You've got to choose who you listen to in life," he said. "The people who can make you feel bad are going to do it. You've got to choose."
__________________
"In your veins runs Scarlet and Gray blood with which there is no quit, no stopping. It makes you relentless and powerful, more so than your opponent."

SFC Ryan Poetsch
101st ABN DIV, Afghanistan
Digg this Post!Add Post to del.icio.usBookmark Post in TechnoratiFurl this Post!Stumble it!Reddit! Share on Facebook!Google bookmark it!Wong this Post!
Reply With Quote
  #20 (permalink)  
Old 07-30-2005, 06:06 PM
Wingate1217's Avatar
Legend
 
Detroit Tigers Detroit Pistons Carolina Panthers Detroit Red Wings Ohio State 48 - Jimmie Johnson

Join Date: Jan 2005
Location: Charlotte, NC
Posts: 2,644
Points: 20,266.24
Bank: 0.00
Total Points: 20,266.24
Wingate1217 is TresselesqueWingate1217 is TresselesqueWingate1217 is Tresselesque
Wingate1217 is TresselesqueWingate1217 is TresselesqueWingate1217 is TresselesqueWingate1217 is TresselesqueWingate1217 is TresselesqueWingate1217 is TresselesqueWingate1217 is TresselesqueWingate1217 is TresselesqueWingate1217 is TresselesqueWingate1217 is TresselesqueWingate1217 is TresselesqueWingate1217 is TresselesqueWingate1217 is TresselesqueWingate1217 is TresselesqueWingate1217 is TresselesqueWingate1217 is TresselesqueWingate1217 is TresselesqueWingate1217 is TresselesqueWingate1217 is TresselesqueWingate1217 is TresselesqueWingate1217 is TresselesqueWingate1217 is TresselesqueWingate1217 is Tresselesque
Again, there are two sides to every story. If the players discussed were not living up to their part of the bargain (i.e. going to class, receiving passing grades, working out regularly, attending all practices and workouts voluntary or not, etc.) they should have the scholarships revoked.

However, if the players were holding up their end and working hard but the coaching staff made a mistake in evaluating their talent level, the revocation is short sided. If that start of stuff starts to happen regularly at SC, Spurrier is going to have a hard time with the HS coaches.

It doesn't sound like this is the case, but not being involved I really don't have a clue who is right and who is wrong. The facts usually find the light of day and hopefully it will in this case.

One thing that does bother me is if the players in question were "doggin it" in practice, why didn't the leadership (other players) call them on it? When I played we policed ourselves in terms of guys taking off a practice. I'm not talking about a guy taking it easy in one practice (because of personal problems, sickness, death in the family, etc.). I am talking about the guys who continually come late to practice, not pay attention in meetings and then screw up on the field, causing all of us to wait, etc.

One thing to consider is that perhaps Spurrier is silent on the reasons for the review is because he does not want to embarrass the players.
Digg this Post!Add Post to del.icio.usBookmark Post in TechnoratiFurl this Post!Stumble it!Reddit! Share on Facebook!Google bookmark it!Wong this Post!
Reply With Quote
  #21 (permalink)  
Old 07-30-2005, 08:18 PM
MililaniBuckeye's Avatar
Haole in da hills
 
BP Donor

Cleveland Indians Cleveland Browns Ohio State

Join Date: May 2003
Location: Mililani, HI
Posts: 22,045
Points: 100,063,573.42
Bank: 0.00
Total Points: 100,063,573.42
MililaniBuckeye is a legend of The 'ShoeMililaniBuckeye is a legend of The 'ShoeMililaniBuckeye is a legend of The 'ShoeMililaniBuckeye is a legend of The 'ShoeMililaniBuckeye is a legend of The 'ShoeMililaniBuckeye is a legend of The 'ShoeMililaniBuckeye is a legend of The 'ShoeMililaniBuckeye is a legend of The 'ShoeMililaniBuckeye is a legend of The 'ShoeMililaniBuckeye is a legend of The 'ShoeMililaniBuckeye is a legend of The 'ShoeMililaniBuckeye is a legend of The 'ShoeMililaniBuckeye is a legend of The 'ShoeMililaniBuckeye is a legend of The 'ShoeMililaniBuckeye is a legend of The 'ShoeMililaniBuckeye is a legend of The 'ShoeMililaniBuckeye is a legend of The 'ShoeMililaniBuckeye is a legend of The 'ShoeMililaniBuckeye is a legend of The 'ShoeMililaniBuckeye is a legend of The 'ShoeMililaniBuckeye is a legend of The 'ShoeMililaniBuckeye is a legend of The 'ShoeMililaniBuckeye is a legend of The 'ShoeMililaniBuckeye is a legend of The 'ShoeMililaniBuckeye is a legend of The 'Shoe
MililaniBuckeye is a legend of The 'ShoeMililaniBuckeye is a legend of The 'ShoeMililaniBuckeye is a legend of The 'ShoeMililaniBuckeye is a legend of The 'ShoeMililaniBuckeye is a legend of The 'ShoeMililaniBuckeye is a legend of The 'ShoeMililaniBuckeye is a legend of The 'ShoeMililaniBuckeye is a legend of The 'ShoeMililaniBuckeye is a legend of The 'ShoeMililaniBuckeye is a legend of The 'ShoeMililaniBuckeye is a legend of The 'ShoeMililaniBuckeye is a legend of The 'ShoeMililaniBuckeye is a legend of The 'ShoeMililaniBuckeye is a legend of The 'ShoeMililaniBuckeye is a legend of The 'ShoeMililaniBuckeye is a legend of The 'ShoeMililaniBuckeye is a legend of The 'ShoeMililaniBuckeye is a legend of The 'ShoeMililaniBuckeye is a legend of The 'ShoeMililaniBuckeye is a legend of The 'ShoeMililaniBuckeye is a legend of The 'ShoeMililaniBuckeye is a legend of The 'ShoeMililaniBuckeye is a legend of The 'ShoeMililaniBuckeye is a legend of The 'ShoeMililaniBuckeye is a legend of The 'Shoe
Quote:
The group went on to say that taking away a "scholarship because you feel an athlete cannot play at the level needed to compete in the Southeastern Conference is unethical."
I disagree with this. Granted, for the most part you shouldn't pull a schollie just becuse you overestimated a kid's abilities. However, there's a reason why schollies are awarded/renewed each year, and that's to make sure that players meet their part of the deal. Things beyond their control (injuries, etc.) should never be considered, but everything else (academic performance, class and practice attendance, effort, ability, etc.) should be. If I have a player who is, say, a senior-to-be and he has fallen off the three-deep at his position and hasn't contributed much during his previous three years, I'm going to tell him he'd better work his way back into the three-deep else I'm giving the schollie to a non-schollie kid ahead of ahead at his position. A scholarship senior should at least be in the three-deep.
__________________

Digg this Post!Add Post to del.icio.usBookmark Post in TechnoratiFurl this Post!Stumble it!Reddit! Share on Facebook!Google bookmark it!Wong this Post!
Reply With Quote
  #22 (permalink)  
Old 07-30-2005, 08:24 PM
jwinslow's Avatar
if I don't take us down the field, bench me
Senior Moderator
 
BP Donor