Quote:
Originally Posted by jimotis4heisman
im not connecting the dots...
(honestly)
|
Quote:
Originally Posted by Bucklion
I'm not getting this either. By your rationale, if you get captured in combat you are somehow less of a soldier (?)...does that applied to getting killed too? Were the people who died (or were captured) storming the Germans on Omaha and Utah beaches somehow less of soldiers than the ones who made it through unscathed? Most soldiers I've talked to say the fact they didn't get hit just means they were lucky.
I know you're not trying to bash the military, I'm just not getting it.
|
My main point is quite simple.... merely serving in the military does not a hero make. But.. it's unassailable. That is... it's extremely unwise for anyone - let a lone a person who's running for office - to say "OK, sure you served in a war, but you're no particular hero"
So... my point is this - I get sick of people giving a free pass to someone merely for serving. Merely serving does not a hero make.
I always hesitate to make such remarks because I realize how it goes against what American's are "allowed" to talk about (Ironically, I'll get a "You can only say that because a soldier died for you" response I'm sure...Which I call Ironic because it completely misses the point I'm trying to make - that is, it's irrelevant.)
There are certain things we say and we don't question... "Military hero" is one of those things. Well... I question it. I don't give you "hero" status just because you went to Viet Nam. I don't give you hero status just because you worked for the NYPD on 9/11. You MAY be such a hero... but... it takes proof, I guess is what I'm saying.
So... my hypo about the rapist friend of my father..... if he serves... and rapes... still a hero? I suppose it depends on if he's running for office and if they find out about the raping.... Is McCain a hero? I don't know... depends on who you believe, I guess. No doubt he's at least served and no doubt he survived intolerable conditions. But... is that a "hero?" Is being a POW instant "Hero" status if you survive? Are all vets heros? If so, doesn't the word "hero" lose meaning?
Not that it much matters... I realize my position on this is highly unpopular and I don't think I'll be saying much more on this topic for a while.