Quote:
Originally Posted by LitlBuck
I totally agree with your comments about Edwards. Sometimes he can make some very good catches but overall I think he drops way too many to be considered the #1 receiver on this team.
|
While he had a bad game and does have regular problems with the dropsies, I'm not gonna crucify him yet. He is very much a #1 reciever. Look at his numbers last year. He's gonna [censored] you off with some drops, but more often you'll love him for the big plays he makes.
Quote:
|
People can say what they like about Winslow but at least he does his talking with his playing abilities. Edwards on the other hand open his mouth too much for what he is bringing to the table.
|
Exactly right. I hated his ass when they drafted him and especially after it became evident he couldn't drive his bike from one end of a parking lot to the other without crashing into a curb and blowing out his knee, but he has heart. He plays his ass off every down and has been pretty well behaved.
Quote:
|
I'm just not sure about Romeo. I don't like his coaching philosophy but you can't judge the season by one game. I have no idea why he kicked that field goal unless he had a over/under bet. He had to be thinking something but the question was what.
|
Bottom line: Romeo is a great coordinator, mediocre to bad head coach. He makes too many mind boggling decisions and seems to coddle players. That was a fun season last year, but it may have given Romeo more rope than I'm rally comfortable with. The FO knows this is a ridiculous schedule and I think barring an absolute disaster of a season, he's gonna be around for a while.
Quote:
|
I don't know why we traded for Corey Williams because he certainly didn't bring anything to the table yesterday and I really did not hear his name that much during the season. However, he is not used to playing in the 3-4 just like Shaun Rogers is not used to playing in that defense but at least Rogers is bringing something. I know it is too late to do this now when I think the Browns would have been better off switching to a 4-3 with the linebackers that they have which is not much. At least with Rogers, Williams, and both Smiths playing up front they might be able to put some pressure on the passer and stuff the run. If we do not get to the passer even Carson Palmer might be able to throw for 300 yards against that defense. I would rather take my chances with some blitzes than letting a QB sit back there completely untouched.
|
Again, I'm not gonna write anybody off after one bad game...especially when I expected to get destroyed. If anything the coaching staff deserves the blame for their apparent romper room preseason preperation.
Quote:
|
I noticed it was referenced above about no contact during the preseason camps. Different coaches have different philosophies about that and if the Browns did have contact and someone would have gotten hurt because of that we probably would be bitching about that.
|
It's a catch-22 with this team. Lord only knows how many injuries they'd have had if they actually had hard contact in drills. But then again, they've looked totally unprepared for 5 games now.
Quote:
|
Let's see what happens next Sunday when they should get Pool, Stallworth, and hopefully Cribbs back. If they take another beating at home next Sunday, things will get ugly for not only Romeo but also for Savage.
|
I think Stallworth neds to get back ASAP. It seemed evident yesterday that Stallworth is
badly needed in the passing game. Steptoe is decent, but Josh is a gamebreaker. Pool...meh. Again, though, Phil and Romeo bought a lot of rope with last season so I don't see them feeling any heat unless this team totally implodes. Pukesburgh looked good though and absolutely own us right now, so my hopes aren't high.