I think that we should step back and consider ourselves lucky to have the problem where we debate who the backup QB is. How many times have you heard something to the effect of the backup QB being the most popular man in town. Not that this discussion isn't interesting because it is... and I have my own opinions here too... but 'tis a far better discussion to be having in theory as opposed to having it for real. And that's a bet that I'd lay 100000:1 on. Wonder why there isn't a "trust the coaches" option here?