This site is supported by the advertisements on it, please disable your AdBlocker so we can continue to provide you with the quality content you expect.
  1. Follow us on Twitter @buckeyeplanet and @bp_recruiting, like us on Facebook! Enjoy a post or article, recommend it to others! BP is only as strong as its community, and we only promote by word of mouth, so share away!
    Dismiss Notice
  2. Consider registering! Fewer and higher quality ads, no emails you don't want, access to all the forums, download game torrents, private messages, polls, Sportsbook, etc. Even if you just want to lurk, there are a lot of good reasons to register!
    Dismiss Notice

Fourth Annual Herbie Awards

Discussion in 'Buckeye Football' started by BuckNutty, Aug 25, 2004.

  1. BuckNutty

    BuckNutty Hear The Drummer Get Wicked Staff Member Bookie

  2. OSUBasketballJunkie

    OSUBasketballJunkie Never Forget 31-0

    I dont see how you dont list Schlegel on that list.......maybe he is trying to be to unbiased if there is such a thing....


    :scum4:
     
  3. DCBuckFan

    DCBuckFan Fark You

    Only thing about Schlegel is that he hasn't even played at tOSU, and he may not even be the starter if all is true about MDA pushing him.
     
  4. sears3820

    sears3820 Sitting around in my underwear.... Staff Member

    I was wondering when my Herbies were going to flareup again.

    Good find Nutty.
     
  5. MililaniBuckeye

    MililaniBuckeye The satanic soulless freight train that is Ohio St Staff Member Tech Admin

    How in the f**k can you not list Mark Dantonio among the top defensive masterminds, and not have A.J. Hawk as one of the best OLBs?
     
  6. BuckeyeNation27

    BuckeyeNation27 Goal Goal USA! Staff Member

    this might be homerish of me to say......but it felt like he was trying too hard to NOT be a homer.

    he either excluded notable buckeyes altogether.....and when he did list them they were at the bottom of the list.
     
  7. CleveBucks

    CleveBucks Serenity now Staff Member

    Seriously... leaving Dantonio off that list is a shame. Way too much hype for the Oklahome defense, when we have been better the last two years. Where were those vaunted D-coords last year when K-state came to play?
     
  8. JohnnyCockfight

    JohnnyCockfight Beer is God's proof that he loves us.

    Uh, doesn't he freely admit that he underdoes his praise to the Buckeyes due to his connection / bias? Cause I think that he does.
     
  9. BuckeyeNation27

    BuckeyeNation27 Goal Goal USA! Staff Member

    im not knocking him for it.....i just thought that i picked up on it a little bit. if thats what he does....good for him. nobody else has the balls to do it *cough*trev*cough*
     
  10. honor_defend

    honor_defend Newbie

    Herbie does try hard not to seem a homer. He probably did screw up with Dantonio and Hawk...what I can't figure out is why even Herbie drools over Sproles from KSU.

    He's not the only one and I can't quite figure out what was so great about him other than he piled up a lot of yards in the Pig12. How many yards did he get against us? Less than 50 or something like that. Sproles is a fraud and the Buckeyes exposed him...and the rest of K-State for that matter.
     
  11. coxew

    coxew Newbie

    I have a strange feeling that Coach Snyder is going to prove to be a better defensive coordinator that Coach Dantonio. I love the guy, but thought our defensive could have been better (yes, I know that's saying a lot as good as they were). He got too lax late in the game with his play calling, allowing teams to get back into the game. Coach Snyder has admitted he's not going to the prevent so early and will attack the offense more. I guess my biggest problem with Dantonio is the fact that he pulled in the reins on the defense so early. Why? If you attack for three quarters and shut a team down and the offense builds a 17 point lead, why change things? You've already proven the opposition can't move or score on you and you don't want to give up the big play. Instead, they drive down the field picking up 10 yards a play, building momentum, and get back into the game. I really hope we don't see any more of this.
     
  12. BuckStocksHere

    BuckStocksHere Semper Fi!

    Let me be the voice of reason here - take off those S&G glasses for a moment please. The guy is anything but a fraud. Yes we shut him down. Does that mean he is a fraud? He had a bad game and our D shut him down. Don't you think players have bad games? What about our D last year vs that stink hole up north? Was our D a "fraud" because of one bad game vs scUM.? of course not.

    I would take him over ANY backs we have on our team. He has PROVEN it. Our guys have done jack squat. The #'s dont' lie.


    Here are some facts:
    - Darren Sproles, Sr. - Sproles has been one of the best players in college football over the last two years with 3,661 career rushing yards and 34 touchdowns to go along with 34 catches for 386 yards and two scores. What's most amazing is how he stays healthy with 653 career touches on a 5-7 frame. He deserved Heisman consideration last year, and he should finally get the respect he deserves this season as the nation's best all-around back.

    Last Year
    Rushing: Darren Sproles
    306 carries for 1986 yds, 16 TDs
     
    Last edited: Aug 26, 2004
  13. FKAGobucks877

    FKAGobucks877 The Most Power-Drunk

    Yeah, what Buckstocks said. Except I wouldn't trade either one of our Frosh for him, simply because they each have 4 years of eligibility left. Yeah, I know they haven't proven anything, but they very well could by the end of the year.

    I do not think Sproles is over-rated, but I also do not think he's going to play very well, or very long, on Sundays. He's just too little.
     
  14. BuckStocksHere

    BuckStocksHere Semper Fi!

    I wouldn't trade our freshmen's 4 years of playing for his 1 either, but that is only because of possible future potential - Sproles has already used most of his up. You could and I will make the argument that I would probably take Sproles 4 years of production over our freshmen's future 4 years. I think there is just too much uncetainty with freshmen to predict greatness. I'll take the proven guys over the prospects nearly every time. I agree also that he won't do much in the league - a lot of GREAT college guys never do.

    This guy is fun to watch though.... all of 5'7 I think.
     
  15. AKAK

    AKAK Mayor of Turkey Balls Falls Staff Member Bookie

    .

    Coxew- I tend to agree, but my biggest knock on Dantonio was predictibility-- I could call the defense from my living room... It was like...uh oh... the opponent has reached our 27 yard line.. okay.. now we'll jsut blitz the hell out of them.

    For the most part I really agreed with his philosophy, excapet that it was so formulaic... Snyder will be more aggressive.. which I think it good... anyway, It should look different since the strength will be coming from the LB position and not the last 2 years of keying everything up front off Will Smith.
     

Share This Page