This site is supported by the advertisements on it, please disable your AdBlocker so we can continue to provide you with the quality content you expect.
  1. Follow us on Twitter @buckeyeplanet and @bp_recruiting, like us on Facebook! Enjoy a post or article, recommend it to others! BP is only as strong as its community, and we only promote by word of mouth, so share away!
    Dismiss Notice
  2. Consider registering! Fewer and higher quality ads, no emails you don't want, access to all the forums, download game torrents, private messages, polls, Sportsbook, etc. Even if you just want to lurk, there are a lot of good reasons to register!
    Dismiss Notice

Most ovverrated player in college football

Discussion in 'Buckeye Football' started by jimotis4heisman, Dec 10, 2004.

  1. CleveBucks

    CleveBucks Serenity now Staff Member

    It starts and ends with Marlin Shazor.
  2. Bestbuck36

    Bestbuck36 Kyle Young man crush. Not ashamed

    Absofuckinglutely! He wasn't even the best linebacker on his team in my opinion. I think Tatupu was better. Either way neither are close to AJ Hawk. This will be shown in the NFL year!
  3. AmeriBuck007

    AmeriBuck007 Honey, Frank the Tank is not coming back

    agreed my thoughts exactly, I dont think he deserves it this year, but he'll have a bright future in the NFL and there aren't too many ppl right now in college football that I would take over Bush.
  4. jwinslow

    jwinslow A MAN OF BETRAYED JUSTICE Staff Member Tourney Pick'em Champ

    I doubt Greene looks any worse to us than Krenzel looked to most non-bucks.

    Sproles was the most disappointing in terms of his season, but I don't think it is his fault (like a Chad Henne vs. OSU, despite the pressure, he couldn't step up for his team). If you put Sproles on USC he'd be in NYC right now if he were switched with Bush. Bush may have done a little better, but only a little. It's hard to be a smaller playmaker if you have no passing or o-line.

    I despise Benson. He deserves to be ignored for his heisman comment. But his situation would be like Pittman putting up those kind of numbers had we never brought Ginn in nor Smith. We had no balance and even if the blockers blocked well there were too many people looking for the predictable running from tressel. I respect his performance a lot this season. But I'm glad he's home watching the heisman show.

    Most disappointing would have to be Kyle Orton. He was not supposed to be amazing, but seemed to be a tough favorite for the Heisman after trashing easy school after easy school. Then the guy just disappeared. It doesn't matter that he put his team in positions to win games, he gave up multiple game-losing fumbles. He has to get my vote for most overrated (without any stipulation about when they were first overrated).
  5. AmeriBuck007

    AmeriBuck007 Honey, Frank the Tank is not coming back

    Can't blame anyone for overhyping EJ he has perfect corner hips and great technique with good enough speed to be a star, he just hasn't panned out yet. I think he still has a good chance to be another great buckeye coner
  6. 7 45 33 48

    7 45 33 48 Freshman

    David Pollack is by far most overrated player in football. He has been living on his sophmore stats the last 2 seasons. I don't know how the hell he could have won the Lombardi and Bednarik. He didn't do anything last year or this year in the games I watched. Will Smith was twice the player Pollack is.
  7. thanks for the input, enjoyed it, the reason was spurred by espnnews anchor something kim, who said he had a legit shot at 3 trophies, i missed the usc-und game i was up in canton and only saw one game of his early and the year and was unimpressed
  8. JXC

    JXC 17-2 since 2001

    I'd rather have Mike Nugent on my team than any of the players previously mentioned.
  9. osugrad21

    osugrad21 Capo Regime Staff Member

    I wish he'd display those CB hips and technique, the ones Duane Long loves to brag about, to everyone else. I've never watched a practice but to me they look like hell in games...
  10. BB73

    BB73 Loves Buckeye History Staff Member Bookie '16 & '17 Upset Contest Winner

    While I'm not a Jason White supporter, to say he may be the worst Heisman trophy winner ever is way off base. He ended up with 40 TD's and 10 Int's last year, even with his 2 bad games at the end.

    Gino Torretta ('92) and Gary Beban ('67) were far worse choices than White or Crouch, who was a very effective runner with poor passing stats.
  11. Naplesbuckeye

    Naplesbuckeye Newbie

    Darren Sproles

    Chris Rix

    Brock Berlin

    The tailback at UCLA

    Marcus Houston

    The WVU team

    Maryland Team

    Purdue Team

    Wisconsin Team

    David Baas (It seems a Michigan OL ha sto be named every year for good measure...Hell Pearson is the best linemen they have)

    Clayton at Oklahoma

    Both corners at LSU


    LT for USC

    Austin whoever TB for PSU

    Bowling Green State University team

    Anyone on NC State
  12. souL

    souL I.bulldoze

    Reggie Bush is soooooooo good. I think he's got the numbers to be a finalist for the Heisman... but I don't think he should win it.

    Braylon Edwards anyone? Drops more balls than Paris Hilton fondles...
  13. Sdgobucks

    Sdgobucks Pig on a wing

    My votes goes to "Snaggle Tooth" (White)
  14. LloydSev

    LloydSev DreamWeaver

    I didn't realize he had quite that many thrown to him.....
  15. OSUG314

    OSUG314 Newbie

    I don't know how Darren Sproles is overrated. He had nobody to help him all year. KSU played three different QB thru the year

    My List:
    Chris Rix
    Brock Berlin
    Jason White
    OU's secondary

Share This Page