This site is supported by the advertisements on it, please disable your AdBlocker so we can continue to provide you with the quality content you expect.
  1. Follow us on Twitter @buckeyeplanet and @bp_recruiting, like us on Facebook! Enjoy a post or article, recommend it to others! BP is only as strong as its community, and we only promote by word of mouth, so share away!
    Dismiss Notice
  2. Consider registering! Fewer and higher quality ads, no emails you don't want, access to all the forums, download game torrents, private messages, polls, Sportsbook, etc. Even if you just want to lurk, there are a lot of good reasons to register!
    Dismiss Notice

Personal Opinion VS Personal Judgement

Discussion in 'Philosophical Musings' started by PennState1985, Dec 3, 2007.

  1. PennState1985

    PennState1985 I R BABOON

    I don't get the appeal of girls kissing girls. To me it's downright disgusting, but I guess whatever floats your boat.
     
  2. BuckeyeFlorida

    BuckeyeFlorida Resident Science Dork

    Paging Thump, paging Thump...
     
  3. Gatorubet

    Gatorubet Loathing All Things Georgia

    [​IMG]
     
    schwab likes this.
  4. MikaBuks44

    MikaBuks44 Newbie

    [​IMG]
     
    PlanetFrnd likes this.
  5. PennState1985

    PennState1985 I R BABOON

    I know you apparently all think it's lame, but I'm conservative leaning so I'm naturally against homosexual acts of any type, male or female. I'll stop there because it'll become a political debate if I take it any further, and this isn't the politics board.
     
  6. OCBucksFan

    OCBucksFan I won a math debate

    [​IMG]
     
  7. Taosman

    Taosman Flatten the Curve

    Pennstate, no ones making you watch! Just change the channel big boy! :tongue2:
    (sarcasm detector activated)
     
  8. OCBuckWife

    OCBuckWife I am the evil monkey in your closet

    I'm sure not everyone thinks it's lame that you feel that way, but it was very lame of you to come into a thread very clearly labeled "girls kissing girls" and thus clearly indicating it's contents and express your judgement about and to everyone in the thread that was/is enjoying it.

    Yes, you are perfectly correct, in the political forums is where that opinion should belong.

    And to get this thread back on track:


    [​IMG]


    Dang, Tao beat me to it....

     
  9. RugbyBuck

    RugbyBuck Our church has no bells.

    Stop there not because of the nature of the board, but, and I can say this with some assurance, because no one here cares what you think about anything. Just to be sure that we weren't missing any sage bromide from Happy Valley, I went back and read your 20 or so posts. Having done so, I'm now confident that we're all set and do not require your participation any further. Surely, there is some kind of Penn State message board (WhineOut.com?) on which your insights will be more fully appreciated.
     
    schwab likes this.
  10. PennState1985

    PennState1985 I R BABOON

    I have not broken any rules, I have not slammed Ohio State ONCE on here, and until there's actually a reason to get rid of me (which there won't be), I'll continue posting. Sorry but you're stuck with me. And no, there's no active Penn State board. I'd join but there's no fun in joining boards where there are only a couple posts a month. This looked like an active college football board, so I thought I'd join.
     
    Last edited: Dec 4, 2007
  11. PennState1985

    PennState1985 I R BABOON

    I'm a person with strong opinions, and if I have an opinion on something, I'm going to say it, no matter how unpopular it is. If you want to drop the subject (like I thought everyone would after the jeering was out of the way), I'd be glad to, but by continuing this "debate" here, it's doing everyone here a disservice and as we both said, it'll do nothing but get the thread off-topic.
     
    Last edited: Dec 4, 2007
  12. OCBuckWife

    OCBuckWife I am the evil monkey in your closet

    Snipped from the Girls Kissing Girls to avoid cross-thread contamination.


    Ok, now that we have the relevant posts re-quoted here to bring in all the back data, I am going to try to address this in a rational manner. As you can see I have moved this to the area of the forum that we have both agreed upon is the correct arena for this "debate."

    My problem here, and why I posted originally, is not that you have opinions or that you have no problem expressing them. We all have opinions, and believe, NONE of us have problems expressing them. :biggrin:

    However, what you did was not just an expression of an opinion.


    You saw a thread labeled clearly as being about girls kissing other girls, and knowing that you are personally disgusted by those actions (and by implication, disgusted by those people who either engage in those acts or enjoy them vicariously), you CHOSE to enter this thread. You CHOSE to view personally objectional content. You then CHOSE to malign and insult others viewing that thread who DO NOT find the content objectional by expressing your personal statement of disgust.

    That was your first mistake. As Taos said, if you don't like the channel and what is playing on it, don't watch it.

    In this context, you did not express an opinion. You passed judgement upon not only the girls who are depicted kissing other girls but also passed judgement upon those of us who do not find such material disgusting. You went OUT OF YOUR WAY to tell us that it was disgusting to you.
    That turns your opinion into a judgement because you took the time to go somewhere you don't like to tell people in there that what they were doing was disgusting.

    Let me repeat my salient point here, and that is that in passing judgement upon the action you therefore pass judgement upon those who do not share your opinon, by implication.

    This was your second mistake.

    You are not the only conservative, I am sure, that doesn't approve of homosexual behaviour, but you are the only one that made a point of entering into a thread about said subject matter and telling those of us viewing and contributing to the thread of your opinion. Take a look back at the thread you dislike so much and I am sure you will notice that anyone else who feels as you do....DOES NOT POST IN THE THREAD.


    That thread is not about the relative moral, religious, ethical or social values, or lack thereof, of homosexual behaviour. That is not what that thread is about. You, briefly, made it so. In a thread that does not invite, that is clearly not about, that has nothing to do with, a discussion or debate of homosexual behaviour does not need, want or deserve those kinds of statements.


    You know this, as evidenced by your near-immediate mention of the political forums, yet you entered the thread and did so anyway. Again, it was not your expression of your opinion to which I objected to, it was the place in which you did it.

    That was your third mistake.

    I hope that this clears up the issue I had with you about it and perhaps explains why you are now rubied up which shows me that others tend to have felt the same way, although I cannot and do not speak for anyone else.
     
  13. Gatorubet

    Gatorubet Loathing All Things Georgia

    So what you're saying is - you approve of leaning but not wide stancing?
     
    Jagdaddy, PlanetFrnd and OCBucksFan like this.
  14. sandgk

    sandgk Watson, Crick & A Twist

    You really ought to see PS1985 in full roar ...
     
  15. methomps

    methomps an imbecility, a stupidity without name

Share This Page