This site is supported by the advertisements on it, please disable your AdBlocker so we can continue to provide you with the quality content you expect.
  1. Follow us on Twitter @buckeyeplanet and @bp_recruiting, like us on Facebook! Enjoy a post or article, recommend it to others! BP is only as strong as its community, and we only promote by word of mouth, so share away!
    Dismiss Notice
  2. Consider registering! Fewer and higher quality ads, no emails you don't want, access to all the forums, download game torrents, private messages, polls, Sportsbook, etc. Even if you just want to lurk, there are a lot of good reasons to register!
    Dismiss Notice

Suspended License

Discussion in 'Open Discussion (Work-safe)' started by buckeyefool, Aug 18, 2004.

  1. buckeyefool

    buckeyefool COBRA!!!!

    I really don't see how this was legal to begin with or how it was upheld. If He is drinking a six pack at home and then passing out, why does the state have the right to take away his license?


    Court Upholds Beer Drinker's License Loss <SMALL>
    </SMALL><SCRIPT language=JavaScript type=text/javascript> writeNewsImg( "Story Image", "http://eimg.net/harvest_inc/NEWS/img/x.gif", "", "" ); </SCRIPT><SMALL>
    </SMALL>
    [size=-2]August 17, 2004 05:39 PM EDT[/size] <SMALL>

    </SMALL>
    HARRISBURG, Pa. - A judge ruled the state can suspend the driver's license of a man who lost his driving privileges after his doctor reported to police that he drank a six-pack of beer a day.

    But the judge also said Keith Emerich may obtain restricted driving privileges as long as he uses a device that tests his blood-alcohol content before starting his car.

    Emerich, 44, a printing company employee, was notified in April he would lose his license, about two months after he disclosed his drinking habit to doctors treating him for an irregular heartbeat.

    A Pennsylvania law from the 1960s requires doctors to report any impairments in patients that could compromise their ability to drive safely.

    Emerich has said he does not drive drunk and argued that he has reduced his beer drinking to weekends and has a clean driving record apart from a drunk-driving conviction when he was 21.

    Emerich's lawyer, Horace Ehrgood, said Tuesday he was mostly happy about the ruling, which was released Monday, because it would enable Emerich to drive again. But he said it did not address the issue of how Emerich can ever prove to officials he can drive safely.

    Ehrgood said no decision had been made on whether to appeal the ruling.

    Emerich said the legal battle has left him "just about tapped out" financially. "I'm being treated like a criminal. The only crime I committed was getting sick and telling the doctor the truth," he said.

    State Department of Transportation spokesman Anthony Haubert said the department was pleased Emerich's license suspension was upheld.
     
  2. BuckeyeNation27

    BuckeyeNation27 Goal Goal USA! Staff Member

    wow....thats messed up.
     
  3. BrutuStrength

    BrutuStrength It's time to bring it! Staff Member

    That's whack! That ruling needs to be changed.
     
  4. BuckNutty

    BuckNutty Hear The Drummer Get Wicked Staff Member Bookie

    I hope Buckskin86 has a bike, the raging Alcoholic that he is :lol:

    Now that the story is out there you'd assume that ridiculous ruling will be overturned.
     
  5. AKAK

    AKAK Mayor of Turkey Balls Falls Staff Member Bookie

    What?

    This dude needs to call all those dudes from the Puerto Rico military base thread... because the man is keeping him down.


    Just another note... it is not illegal to drink and then drive... its illegal to drink too much and then drive... if this guy weighs a lot... hell 6 might not even put him over the limit... (And if he drinks six every day.. he's blowing his Atkins plan... so he's probably not too skinny)

    What a freaking joke.

    They might as well hook these to your car every time you walk out of the liquor store.
     
  6. chille37

    chille37 Freshman

    I live in Harrisburg, and the drinking rules around here are ridiculous I can't even drink a beer on my own front porch without the cops saying something.
     
  7. AKAK

    AKAK Mayor of Turkey Balls Falls Staff Member Bookie

    Did Pennsylvania get the memo that the 18th Amendment was... in fact... repealed?
     
  8. BrutuStrength

    BrutuStrength It's time to bring it! Staff Member

    On the radio they said he's 6'0" and 250 lbs. According to the charts used by the PA traffic department, he can have 6 beers in 2 hours and still be below the legal limit in PA.

    Regarding the Atkins thing, if he's drinking Miller Light, then that's just around 20 carbs a day for a 6 pack. Well within Atkins guidelines (not good for the first 2 weeks though, since alcohol is a no-no during that time.)
     
  9. methomps

    methomps an imbecility, a stupidity without name

    That guy should out the name of his doctor.
     
  10. HineyBuck

    HineyBuck Old newb

    This is a disturbing ruling for several reasons. What bothers me most is the doctor reporting this guy (to whom? the DMV?) Whatever happened to doctor-patient confidentiality and the legal privilege this communication used to enjoy? I understand this privilege has its limits (reporting incest, physical abuse of kids, and such). But reporting any impairment that might affect driving to another public agency, which can then make the information even more public through the legal process, seems way out of line. If you can't be completely honest with your doctor (for fear of getting reported), that's got to jeopardize health care and the integrity of the health care delivery system.

    Maybe the BuckeyePlanet physician who practices in Pennsylvania can comment on this.
     
  11. AKAK

    AKAK Mayor of Turkey Balls Falls Staff Member Bookie

    I'll keep these stats in mind.... :wink2:
     
  12. daddyphatsacs

    daddyphatsacs Let the cards fall... Staff Member

    If I was that guy I would run a smear campaign on my doctor. What a fucking joke, this guy has not had any alcohol citations since he was 21, and now they throw that in his car? Bullshit. I understand the need to crack down on drunk driving, and I do not condone it by any stretch, but don't you think that they could use some of the time and money that they have put into this ordeal and use it to crack down on the "real" bad guys?
     
  13. BuckeyeInTheBoro

    BuckeyeInTheBoro This space left intentionally blank

    Why stop here? If we are going to use the courts to prevent possible future risky behaviour in cars we should do it right!

    First we could have people on a restricted license (due to requiring glasses or contacts) have to pass a vision test each time they get in their car.
    Old people could take a reflex test.
    Cell phones could be automatically disabled.
    Females should have the vanity mirrors removed as they might use them to put on make-up.
    No bears should ever be allowed to drive as some have shown a propensity for binge drinking. Of course there may be other reasons too.
    Radios should be tuned before you get in and locked automatically once the car is in gear.
    If you've EVER used any drug you should have to pee into a little device on the side of the car to activate the ignition.
    After the pharmacist gives you your "do not operate heavy machinery" medication he should call the DMV to have your license revoked.

    I'm sure I've missed some... any suggestions?
     
  14. BuckeyeNation27

    BuckeyeNation27 Goal Goal USA! Staff Member

    im the love doctor.......does that count?
     
  15. HineyBuck

    HineyBuck Old newb

    Republicans are angry.

    Democrats are wishy-washy and indecisive.

    Obviously none of them should be allowed to drive.
     

Share This Page