BPCFFB 2008 Season?

[BuckeyeNation27]

I can confirm that's how it has been done in the past. Any attempts to alter this will be met with strong opposition despite the fact that I'm no longer in charge.

 

[Bestbuck36]

I think I'd still like us not to be able to keep more than 6 players at a time. I guess I'd be voting for A with a stipulation.

 

[Piney]

A: 2
B: 4
C: 2

Still need votes from

kinch
scooter
oneshot
buckeyesoldier

 

[scooter1369]

A: 2
B: 5
C: 2

Still need votes from

kinch
oneshot
buckeyesoldier

Voted. After some thought, sacrificing the now for the benefit of the future is what a keeper league is about. By taking away a teams fair option to continue to improve seems to go against the spirit of a keeper league.

in the NFL, if you land a great player in the second round, losing your next second round pick a year later as punishment for drafting well a year prior defeats the purpose.

I vote for B

 

[Oneshot]

I vote B.

Can we talk about how much my team rocks, now.

 

[BuckeyeSoldier]

Well that makes it 2-6-2 with only two votes left so its pretty much wrapped up unless my vote is worth 3 because i rock so hard.

I vote B.

Can we talk about how much my team rocks, now.

 

[BuckeyeSoldier]

and Julio Jones better fucking rock cuz i just realized i wasted my 2000th post on his ass!

 

[kinch]

Choices are:

A. Lose a pick for each kept player, starting at round 1 and losing the pick in each successive round for each player kept. (Keep 6 players, lose your pick in rounds 1-6)
B. Lose a pick for each kept player, starting at round 18 and losing the pick in each prior round for each player kept. Keep 6 players, lose your pick in rounds 13-18)
C. Lose a pick for each kept player in the round corresponding to the round in which the kept player was drafted.



NOTE - For choice C, we'd still have to figure out how to handle kept players that were added mid-season.


My vote is for option C.

C being too complicated for my simple often drunken mind, I would vote for losing picks in rounds 3, 5, 7 and 9 (or similar). I don't like losing picks just at the end or the beginning.

That said, I definitely am against A, and against losing early picks, as it defeats some of the purpose of the keeper league. So I guess I go for B, given the options available. . .

 

[Piney]

Well that makes it 2-6-2 with only two votes left so its pretty much wrapped up unless my vote is worth 3 because i rock so hard.

Yep, Option B now wins.

Of course this issue can be reopened next year while we are drafting as we see how it works out.

 

[FKAGobucks877]

Yep, Option B now wins.

Of course this issue can be reopened next year [strike]while[/strike] before we [strike]are[/strike] draft[strike]ing[/strike] as we see how it works out.

FIFY