-
Follow us on Twitter @buckeyeplanet and @bp_recruiting, like us on Facebook! Enjoy a post or article, recommend it to others! BP is only as strong as its community, and we only promote by word of mouth, so share away!
- Thread starter FKAGobucks877
- Start date
Derek2k3
Banned
I'll keep Peyton Manning and Steve Smith.
So, here's the updated list:
Padraig - MJD & Larry Fitzgerald
Saccamano - AP & McNabb
Bucklion - Stephen Jackson & Brandon Jacobs
Ahiacitian - Michael Turner & Chris Johnson
jlb's friend - Antonio Bryant & Tony Gonzales
BuckTwenty - Brees & Slaton
jlb - Matt Forte & Randy Moss
jwins - DeAngelo Williams & Frank Gore
Derek2k3 - Peyton Manning & Steve Smith
So, here's the updated list:
Padraig - MJD & Larry Fitzgerald
Saccamano - AP & McNabb
Bucklion - Stephen Jackson & Brandon Jacobs
Ahiacitian - Michael Turner & Chris Johnson
jlb's friend - Antonio Bryant & Tony Gonzales
BuckTwenty - Brees & Slaton
jlb - Matt Forte & Randy Moss
jwins - DeAngelo Williams & Frank Gore
Derek2k3 - Peyton Manning & Steve Smith
Upvote
0
That just leaves scarletandgrey.....
2 Keepers due today. If you plan on making changes, speak now or.....
Draft 1 week from today...8 p.m.
:osu:
2 Keepers due today. If you plan on making changes, speak now or.....
Draft 1 week from today...8 p.m.
:osu:
Upvote
0
scarletandgray PMed me with his keepers.
He's holding on to Anquan Boldin & Santana Moss.
Here's the final keeper list, unless someone wants to make a change before the end of the day:
Padraig - MJD & Larry Fitzgerald
Saccamano - AP & McNabb
Bucklion - Stephen Jackson & Brandon Jacobs
Ahiacitian - Michael Turner & Chris Johnson
jlb's friend - Antonio Bryant & Tony Gonzales
BuckTwenty - Brees & Slaton
jlb - Matt Forte & Randy Moss
jwins - DeAngelo Williams & Frank Gore
Derek2k3 - Peyton Manning & Steve Smith
scarletandgray - Anquan Boldin & Santana Moss
He's holding on to Anquan Boldin & Santana Moss.
Here's the final keeper list, unless someone wants to make a change before the end of the day:
Padraig - MJD & Larry Fitzgerald
Saccamano - AP & McNabb
Bucklion - Stephen Jackson & Brandon Jacobs
Ahiacitian - Michael Turner & Chris Johnson
jlb's friend - Antonio Bryant & Tony Gonzales
BuckTwenty - Brees & Slaton
jlb - Matt Forte & Randy Moss
jwins - DeAngelo Williams & Frank Gore
Derek2k3 - Peyton Manning & Steve Smith
scarletandgray - Anquan Boldin & Santana Moss
Upvote
0
who would you have kept? I just went back and found the teams.....and I don't know if I would have kept anybodyDefinitely not doubting you
...just thought his 2 keepers were pretty clear cut.
To each his own I guess
Upvote
0
BuckeyeNation27;1522489; said:who would you have kept? I just went back and found the teams.....and I don't know if I would have kept anybody
I like Greg Jennings & Vincent Jackson with their QBs and the offensive systems they're both in over Bryant & Gonzo from his team.
Not that he should keep who I like
....follow his own heart, I say 
Upvote
0
I would've kept Gonzalez & Jennings (instead of Bryant) if I were him, but his options do stink.
Upvote
0
scarletandgrey
Cleverly disguised as a responsible adult!
Did you see mine...jlb1705;1522500; said:
I'm never going to be able to get out of this hole. I don't have a decent starting running back or QB and won't be able to really get one in the draft with everyone holding themOh and do i get first pick since I pulled a Detroit and didn't win a game last year.
Upvote
0
Yeah, you have the first pick. Here's the draft order again for the first round:
- The S&G Show (scarletandgrey)
- New Carlisle (jlb's friend - not on BP)
- The Soup Vixens (jlb1705)
- Charlie Luvs Burgers (BuckTwenty)
- SuperFanChaChi (Padraig)
- Spybait (jwinslow)
- Saccamano's Storks (Bob Saccamano)
- Appalachia Moonshine (Ahiacitian)
- Boll Weevils (Bucklion, formerly SparkyOSU)
- Psycho D (Derek2K3, formerly FKA)
Upvote
0
jwinslow;1510950; said:
OK, I just figured out how to make it so you lose your pick for the round where you drafted your keeper.
It turns out that the way Yahoo is set up, when I assign the keepers I'm assigning them to a pick in this year's draft. If we go forward with the way we had been assuming it would work I would enter in all of our keepers as our picks for the first two rounds, and our live draft next week would have us starting with with round 3. If we want to lose your pick for where you previously drafted your keeper, then we'll start with round 1 and the pick for your keeper will already be made when we reach that point in the draft where you drafted them last year.
I don't mind either way, and I understand if people think it's too late to make a change. I kinda like the idea of losing the pick where you drafted them now that I know that we have the capability though. Speak up and tell me what you want to do. I'll ask my friend too when I see him tomorrow, though I'm sure he doesn't care one way or the other.
Here's the results of last year's draft for reference:
Last edited by a moderator:
Upvote
0
scarletandgrey
Cleverly disguised as a responsible adult!
I like the idea of losing the pick where you picked up the player last year
Upvote
0
I agree, but I'm new, so my opinion doesn't really count that much. Y'all decide and I can do either.
Upvote
0
Sweet, I'm obviously in favor of this change. Here is my proposal for the rules:
1. You can keep 0-2 players from the previous year.
2. Keeping a drafted player costs you their draft slot (round) in the upcoming draft.
3. Keeping a free agent pickup will cost you a seventh round pick.
4. You can keep a keeper, but it costs you their draft slot minus the number of years they were kept.
- Carson Palmer... drafted 5th rd. Keeper yr 1 costs a 5th, 2nd yr costs a 3rd, 3rd yr costs a 2nd, 4th yr he's a free agent (see below)
5. A player can only be kept for 3 years total even if traded. After that, he becomes part of the draft again.
6. If a player is traded, he maintains his keeper value. Step 4's example still holds true if Carson is traded at any point.
1. You can keep 0-2 players from the previous year.
2. Keeping a drafted player costs you their draft slot (round) in the upcoming draft.
3. Keeping a free agent pickup will cost you a seventh round pick.
4. You can keep a keeper, but it costs you their draft slot minus the number of years they were kept.
- Carson Palmer... drafted 5th rd. Keeper yr 1 costs a 5th, 2nd yr costs a 3rd, 3rd yr costs a 2nd, 4th yr he's a free agent (see below)
5. A player can only be kept for 3 years total even if traded. After that, he becomes part of the draft again.
6. If a player is traded, he maintains his keeper value. Step 4's example still holds true if Carson is traded at any point.
Upvote
0
This system adds a lot more strategy to who you draft, maintains more interest for roster management for those with bad seasons, etc.
Upvote
0
Please check jlb's list above. I am adding the players on roster that were not drafted. If any of these players were traded, please post that. Otherwise they will be worth 7th round picks.
This is highway robbery if all of these are waiver wire pickups.
Upvote
0