Here are some of the great drafts by year showing hall of famers only...
1957
Paul Hornung, QB/HB, Notre Dame - 1st Round (1st overall) by Green Bay Packers
Len Dawson, QB, Purdue - 1st Round (5th overall) by Pittsburgh Steelers
Jim Brown, FB, Syracuse - 1st Round (6th overall) by Cleveland Browns
Jim Parker, T/G, Ohio State - 1st Round (8th overall) by Baltimore Colts
Tommy McDonald, WR, Oklahoma - 3rd Round (31st overall) by Philadelphia Eagles
Sonny Jurgensen, QB, Duke - 4th Round (43rd overall) by Philadelphia Eagles
Henry Jordan, DT, Virginia - 5th Round (52nd overall) by Cleveland Browns
Don Maynard, WR/HB, Texas Western - 9th Round (109th overall) by New York Giants
1961
Mike Ditka, TE, Pittsburgh - 1st Round (5th overall) by Chicago Bears
(Also drafted in 1st round of 1961 AFL Draft by the Houston Oilers.)
Jimmy Johnson, CB, UCLA - 1st Round (6th overall) by San Francisco 49ers
(Also drafted in 4th round of 1961 AFL Draft by the Los Angeles Chargers.)
Herb Adderley, HB, Michigan State - 1st Round (12th overall) by Green Bay Packers
(Also drafted in 2nd round of 1961 AFL Draft by the New York Titans.)
Bob Lilly, DT, Texas Christian - 1st Round (13th overall) by Dallas Cowboys
(Also drafted in 2nd round of 1961 AFL Draft by the Dallas Texans.)
Billy Shaw, G, Georgia Tech - 2nd Round by Buffalo Bills
(Also selected in the 14th round - 184th overall - of 1961 NFL Draft by the Dallas Cowboys.)
Fran Tarkenton, QB, Georgia - 3rd Round (29th overall) by Minnesota Vikings
(Also drafted in 5th round of 1961 AFL Draft by the Boston Patriots.)
David "Deacon" Jones, DE, South Carolina St., Mississippi Vocational - 14th Round (186th overall) by Los Angeles Rams
1964
Bob Brown, T, Nebraska – 1st Round (2nd overall) by Philadelphia Eagles
(Also drafted in 1st round – 1st overall – of the 1964 AFL Draft by Denver Broncos)
Carl Eller, DE, Minnesota – 1st Round (6th overall) by Minnesota Vikings
(Also drafted in 1st round – 5th overall – of the 1964 AFL Draft by Buffalo Bills)
Charley Taylor, HB/SE, Arizona State - 1st Round (3rd overall) by Washington Redskins
(Also drafted in 2nd round - 9th overall - of 1964 AFL Draft by the Houston Oilers.)
Paul Warfield, WR, Ohio State - 1st Round (11th overall) by Cleveland Browns
(Also drafted in 4th round - 28th overall - of 1964 AFL Draft by the Buffalo Bills.)
Mel Renfro, DB, Oregon - 2nd Round (17th overall) by Dallas Cowboys
(Also drafted in 10th round - 79th overall - of 1964 AFL Draft by the Oakland Raiders.)
Paul Krause, S, Iowa - 2nd Round (18th overall) by Washington Redskins
(Also drafted in 12th round - 89th overall - of 1964 AFL Draft by the Denver Broncos.)
Dave Wilcox, LB, Boise Junior College, Oregon - 3rd Round (29th overall) by San Francisco 49ers
(Also drafted in 6th round - 46th overall - of 1964 AFL Draft by Houston Oilers.)
Leroy Kelly, RB, Morgan State - 8th Round (110th overall) by Cleveland Browns
Roger Staubach, QB, New Mexico Military, Navy - 10th Round (129th overall) by Dallas Cowboys
(Drafted as a future selection. Also drafted as a future selection in 16th round - 122nd overall - of 1964 AFL Draft by the Kansas City Chiefs.)
1974
Lynn Swann, WR, USC - 1st Round (21st overall) by Pittsburgh Steelers
Dave Casper, WR, Notre Dame - 2nd Round (44th overall) by Oakland Raiders
Jack Lambert, LB, Kent State - 2nd Round (46th overall) by Pittsburgh Steelers
John Stallworth, WR, Alabama A&M - 4th Round (82nd overall) by Pittsburgh Steelers
Mike Webster, C, Wisconsin - 5th Round (125th overall) by Pittsburgh Steelers
1981
Lawrence Taylor, LB, North Carolina - 1st Round (2nd overall) by New York Giants
Ronnie Lott, DB, USC - 1st Round (8th overall) by San Francisco 49ers
Mike Singletary, LB, Baylor - 2nd Round (38th overall) by Chicago Bears
Howie Long, DE, Villanova - 2nd Round (48th overall) by Oakland Raiders