• Follow us on Twitter @buckeyeplanet and @bp_recruiting, like us on Facebook! Enjoy a post or article, recommend it to others! BP is only as strong as its community, and we only promote by word of mouth, so share away!
  • Consider registering! Fewer and higher quality ads, no emails you don't want, access to all the forums, download game torrents, private messages, polls, Sportsbook, etc. Even if you just want to lurk, there are a lot of good reasons to register!

The Maurice Clarett Saga Unfolds (Merged)

He said ... they said - 11/9/04

HE SAID (Quotes From the original ESPN Articles):


Maurice Clarett
Too numerous to list. Please read the ESPN articles, as all his quotes originate from there.



Richard McNutt
http://sports.espn.go.com/ncf/news/story?id=1919258
But Cooper's account differs from that of Richard McNutt, a cornerback who worked on another landscaping crew. McNutt says he did anything his crew manager asked. "I can only speak for myself. All I know is I worked." (After an ankle injury ended his career, McNutt became a student-assistant for head coach Jim Tressel; he now coaches the secondary at D3 Washington & Jefferson in Pennsylvania.)



Rafael & Sam Maldonado
http://sports.espn.go.com/ncf/news/story?id=1919255
On a fall Friday morning, Buckeyes coach John Cooper sat down with Sammy's family in their living room. Rafael Maldonado, a street-tough native of Puerto Rico who'd gone from washing cars to owning a chunk of 55 New York City parking garages, didn't pull any punches. "You're getting a very good football player," he said. "But you're also getting a pain in the ass."

Despite a solid spring and summer that got him up to No. 2 on the depth chart before that next season, Maldonado was on the sideline when August camp opened. He was asked only to participate in sprints at the end of practice, while Wells, now the starter, and freshman Lydell Ross, one of Tressel's first recruits, shared the running back duties. "I didn't know what I'd done wrong," Maldonado says. "I think Tressel wanted the guys he recruited, not the players who were already there."

Sammy's mother, Nereyda, came to campus in September and videotaped two weeks of her son standing with his arms crossed during all the drills. Then Rafael flew to Columbus for a face-to-face with the coaches. He says when he asked Tressel why his boy wasn't playing, the coach told him Sammy made too many mistakes in practice. Pressed again, Tressel insisted the kid sat because of blunders.

"You're a liar," Rafael shot back. "I've seen two weeks of tape, and Sammy hasn't even put on his helmet."

The Maldonados say that Tressel looked stunned when running backs coach Tim Spencer (now with the Chicago Bears) confirmed that Nereyda had attended practice, and they add that the head coach quickly shuffled them out of his office. Sammy barely spoke with the staff the rest of the season; he finished with 39 carries for 168 yards. "I was just some body," he says, "basically a walk-on." (Ohio State has declined to discuss anything about Maldonado.)

IN SIX academic quarters at Ohio State, Maldonado had earned a decent number of credits (his 57 were the equivalent of about 40 at a semester school). He compiled a 2.3 GPA and had never lost his eligibility. But his coursework included four credits for playing football, three for Tressel's Coaching Football class, 10 for remedial reading, 10 for remedial math and three for Issues Affecting Student Athletes. Six other credits wouldn't transfer because he earned D's in two classes. Maldonado couldn't understand how he had earned only 17 transferable credits in two years. Even today the number pinballs around his head. "What kind of degree can you get from Ohio State if none of your classes count at other colleges?" he asks.

Not much of one, according to The Drake Group, an NCAA watchdog. Members of the organization refer to schools like Ohio State as "football factories" that offer soft courses designed to keep players on the field. "The purpose isn't to educate and graduate," says Drake Group associate director David Ridpath. "They're eligibility mills."

Maldonado figured that Friedgen wouldn't even offer a spot once the coach got wind of his transcript. The player needed to crunch the equivalent of 43 semester credits into one year just to become eligible at Maryland. He underestimated Friedgen, but just barely.

The coach told Sammy he had to get B's in six credits of summer coursework. If he was late, or missed one class or a study hall, there would be no scholarship. Assistant coach Dave Sollazzo, another Harrison native, repositioned his desk to overlook the steps outside Byrd Stadium. Every morning at 7, Maldonado climbed down the 50 steps from the street above, gave a tired wave, then wobbled over to study hall. Sammy got his B's-and his scholarship.

Friedgen was impressed. He had seen his share of transfers over the years, but none with such a barren transcript. "It wasn't his fault," the coach says. "They had him in a bunch of classes that he shouldn't have been in."

Maldonado says the curriculum was not his idea. "Over there, they just put you in classes," he says. "I let them take care of my schedule.

I wish I wouldn't have."



Marco Cooper & Curtis Crosby
http://sports.espn.go.com/ncf/news/story?id=1919258
Marco Cooper, a linebacker suspended after two drug-possession arrests, says he enjoyed perks described by Clarett. When Cooper needed wheels, he says he went to a local Dodge dealer, got keys to a car and was allowed to return it whenever. Cooper never paid or signed papers. "There's no records for that stuff," he says. "There can't be." Just as there are no records for signed helmets and balls he says players use as currency around town for cars and clothing. "It starts at the No. 1 locker and goes all the way around the room," he continues. "You don't even know who you're signing for."

Cooper says a teammate once came home with a friend and some furniture for their apartment. The friend, an OSU student, was the son of a prominent booster. "He gave us furniture all the time," Cooper says. "At least $2,000 worth of nice tables and couches."

In an interview last December, Curtis Crosby, an ex-Buckeye cornerback from Columbus, said he and other players accepted the same friend's generosity. He claimed that five to 10 teammates would go out to eat, none of them seeing the tabs for meals that cost hundreds of dollars. Several former players say there are benefits to playing for OSU and coach Jim Tressel. Like Clarett, Cooper says he worked a no-show landscaping job set up through the football staff and would come and go as he pleased. He says he was paid $10 to $12 an hour and always put down in for 30 hours. "I never worked 30 hours." He adds that he received at least $2,600 in cash and never filed paperwork or went through the compliance office. He knows at least eight teammates who did the same. Crosby also says he worked bogus jobs.



Chris Vance
http://sports.espn.go.com/ncf/news/story?id=1919258
Chris Vance, a star wideout in 2001-02, also denies seeing any improper benefits but says he believes Clarett. "I don't think he's lying. If he feels it's right to speak out, then I'm behind him 100%."



LeAndre Boone
http://sports.espn.go.com/ncf/news/story?id=1919258
In two years at OSU, LeAndre Boone says he took whatever courses his athletic adviser suggested: "He'd say, 'Take this class; this professor loves football players.'" After two years Boone left for D1-AA Hampton, where he could play right away. But he went from academic junior at Ohio State to barely a sophmore at Hampton. After playing one game he was found to have a career-ending heart condition, and he's since moved with his wife and two daughters to the one place he knew he could get a degree: Ohio State.



Fred Sturrup
http://sports.espn.go.com/ncf/news/story?id=1919258
Despite acing courses like Officiating Softball and Power Volleyball, Fred Sturrup (in car, left) became academically ineligible for 2001 and lost his scholarship. He thought about leaving and met with Youngstown State coaches, but after hearing transcript horror stories from teammates, he asked for a chance to stay. To get through spring ball while he got his grades in order, he unloaded furniture for $7.50 an hour. He'd ask teammates for quarters to make phone calls, then spend them once a day on Wendy's 99-cent menu. For four months he lived in his 1971 Cadillac. If Sturrup made a mistake, he says, coaches ran him until he was exhausted.

"I thought they were going to kill him," Crosby says.

Sturrup has given up on being a Buckeye, but not on his education. He hopes to graduate from Ohio State this spring. "They stuck their foot in my ass," he says. "But I'm not letting them stop me from getting my degree."
 
Last edited:
Upvote 0
He said ... they said - 11/10/04

11/10/04 Articles:

Drew Carter
http://www.dispatch.com/football/football.php?story=dispatch/2004/11/10/20041110-B1-04.html&chck=t
Maurice Clarett surprised his former teammates yesterday, not only by telling ESPN that he received improper benefits and favors while at Ohio State, but by saying that he wasn’t the only player who did.

"It seemed like he was saying everybody on the team was getting help and getting stuff for free. He doesn’t know," said former receiver Drew Carter, now with the NFL Carolina Panthers. "It is a free country, and if he wants to come clean, that’s more power to him. But to put us in the situation where we were doing that with him, that’s wrong."



Troy Smith
http://www.dispatch.com/football/football.php?story=dispatch/2004/11/10/20041110-B1-04.html&chck=t
It caught even the current players off guard, said quarterback Troy Smith, who considers Clarett a friend.

"It was a surprise to me today, with the stuff hitting ESPN like that," Smith said.

"We’re getting ready to go out to practice, and that’s the buzz around the team, about one of our teammates who was here in the past. It’s sad to hear from him and see him in a situation like this, but I wish it didn’t turn out like this."

Yet when asked if he considered Clarett a truthful person, Smith said, "Oh, yeah."

Besides, "Before, when I was talking to him and had been interacting with him, I couldn’t speak for him then, because he’s sort of unpredictable in situations," Smith said. "But I sit down sometimes and I pray for him, because you never know what can happen to somebody."



Dustin Fox
http://www.dispatch.com/football/football.php?story=dispatch/2004/11/10/20041110-B1-04.html&chck=t
Still, no one contacted yesterday corroborated Clarett’s story of ill-gotten gains for himself or teammates. Most said they didn’t even know much about him.

"He was kind of a loner, so we didn’t talk to him that much and know what he was doing in his personal life," cornerback Dustin Fox said

Clarett asserted in an article in ESPN The Magazine that he took one for the team during the NCAA investigation that eventually led to his suspension last year. By that he meant he refused to name other players he thought were also getting special treatment.

"That could bug you a little bit, because I don’t think that guys on our team were taking part in illegal activity," Fox said.



Tim Anderson
http://www.dispatch.com/football/football.php?story=dispatch/2004/11/10/20041110-B1-04.html&chck=t
Tim Anderson said he didn’t. A defensive tackle on the 2002 national championship team and now with the Buffalo Bills, Anderson thought he knew why Clarett bared his soul.

"I almost look at it as a situation where an individual with an amazing ability to play a certain game blew his opportunity," Anderson said. "And ever since he blew his opportunity, he wants to bring other people down with him.

"It’s unfortunate. He’s a good guy. He made some mistakes, as everyone does. Instead of owning up to them, he tried to cover them up with more mistakes. Now he is trying to pin everything back on the university, like he did a year ago when all of this negative publicity began."



Tom Friend
http://www.dispatch.com/football/football.php?story=dispatch/2004/11/10/20041110-B1-00.html&chck=t
Clarett’s intent, however, was not to bring down the program, said Friend, who began work on the story when someone close to Clarett contacted him in October to say the player wanted to talk.

"The discussion was, ‘Let’s clear the air,’ not, ‘Let’s get Ohio State.’ That was the context of the whole thing, although, ultimately, Ohio State may get dragged in," Friend said.

http://www.dispatch.com/football/football.php?story=dispatch/2004/11/10/20041110-B3-00.html
Think that happened anywhere in the NFL yesterday? Apparently, Clarett does. Or at least that was his stated reason for coming out with both guns blazing against Ohio State in a story written by ESPN the Magazine’s Tom Friend. To quote Friend: "He needed NFL GMs to know that he hadn’t been the nuisance at Ohio State that he was made out to be."



Marco Cooper
http://www.dispatch.com/football/football.php?story=dispatch/2004/11/10/20041110-B1-00.html&chck=t
Contacted by The Dispatch yesterday, Cooper denied that he received the benefits from boosters.

"Basically I’m saying the things they said — boosters getting me jobs so I didn’t have to go to work, or boosters giving me money to furnish my house or furnishing my house for me, or me getting cars based on being with the program — that kind of stuff never happened," Cooper said.

http://www.cleveland.com/osufootball/plaindealer/index.ssf?/base/sports/1100082916218050.xml
ESPN.com said former OSU player Marco Cooper corroborated Clarett's story that OSU players receive cars and are paid for jobs without actually performing the work.

Cooper, however, on Tuesday night appeared on WBNS-TV in Columbus and said ESPN.com misquoted him and that he was never paid for a job he did not perform.




Thom McDaniels
http://www.dispatch.com/football/football.php?story=dispatch/2004/11/10/20041110-B3-00.html
"The logic behind coming out with these allegations is flawed," said Thom McDaniels, Clarett’s former high-school coach at Warren Harding. "I don’t think behaving this way will endear him to anybody. . . . I presume it’s all fabrication. I’ve known (Ohio State coach) Jimmy Tressel a long time. He’s challenging Jimmy’s reputation with his own, and Maurice loses that challenge."

http://www.daytondailynews.com/sports/content/sports/osu/daily/1110osufbside.html
Clarett made scandalous charges about the Ohio State football program to ESPN: The Magazine in what he said was an effort to clear his name before next year's draft.

"That doesn't make any sense," Warren Harding High School coach Thom McDaniels said. "Coming forth with those kinds of allegations can't enhance his reputation or marketability to the NFL because it's not honorable behavior."

Once considered a mentor for Clarett, McDaniels has fallen out of favor because of his refusal to coddle the temperamental star.

He said the outburst in the magazine is "consistent with the counsel and advice he's been getting lately and consistent with the behavior he's shown lately."

A longtime coach at state power Canton McKinley, McDaniels has sent a stream of players to OSU and other major colleges, and he refuses to believe Clarett's allegations are true.

"I've known Jim Tressel a lot longer than I've known Maurice," McDaniels said. "But in a challenge of honor and integrity between Jim Tressel and Maurice, Jim Tressel wins that contest hands down."

http://www.cleveland.com/osufootball/plaindealer/index.ssf?/base/sports/1100082916218050.xml
Thom McDaniels, who coached Clarett at Warren Harding High School, puts no stock in the allegations.

"He's challenging Jimmy Tressel's reputation and integrity with his own," McDaniels said of Clarett. "In that matchup, Jim Tressel wins 100 out of 100 times. Whoever suggested or advised [Clarett] to do this, their logic is pretty bad.

"I've known Jim Tressel a long time. There is nothing, not one thing in my entire experience with him, that permits me to believe any of this. Of all the people that I know who are honorable and full of integrity, he stands at the top and at the beginning of that list."

http://www.ohio.com/mld/ohio/sports/10140446.htm
Clarett's former high school coach, Thom McDaniels of Warren G. Harding, thinks the running back is taking bad advice and making poor decisions. McDaniels hasn't spoken to Clarett since April.

``I think it makes a sad story even sadder,'' McDaniels said. ``I guess I'm kind of confused. I don't see how this would clear his name. Whoever is giving him advice is using a different logic than I do.''



Unnamed NFL executive
http://www.dispatch.com/football/football.php?story=dispatch/2004/11/10/20041110-B3-00.html
"I don’t think him saying that is going to help him at all," one NFL executive, who asked to remain anonymous, said last night. "It’s added more (evidence) of him making bad decisions. I don’t know what he’s thinking. To me, it’s almost like a get-even type of deal."

"You ask him questions and things were never his fault," he said. "You’d ask serious questions and he’d laugh and giggle."

"I think the more you know about him," the NFL exec said, "the more concerned you are."



Unnamed NFL executive
http://www.ohio.com/mld/ohio/sports/10140446.htm
One NFL general manager, speaking on condition of anonymity, said Clarett's image will only be hurt by going public with the allegations.

``In my opinion it confirms more of what a jerk he is,'' the general manager said. ``It demonstrates how unstable, undependable and unreliable that he is. There is a way to handle these things and that certainly is not the way.

``What it shows to the NFL is he won't be loyal to anyone. If Maurice doesn't get his way, he won't hesitate to stab you in the back.''



Unnamed NFL executive
http://www.ohio.com/mld/ohio/sports/10140446.htm
Another NFL general manager said he doesn't think Clarett's comments substantially impact his draft status, but concedes character is an issue in evaluating talent.

``If a kid doesn't have any issues and has the same type talent, you're going to take that player - it's less risk,'' the GM said. ``But you're dealing with a 20-year-old kid. You've got to factor that in. He's going to mature between now and the draft and once he gets to our level.''



Rob Knight
http://www.cleveland.com/osufootball/plaindealer/index.ssf?/base/sports/1100082916218050.xml
Rob Knight, general sales manager at McDaniel Automotive, said Clarett had possession of the car only overnight after a test drive and that the vehicle was not repossessed.

"All we tried to do was sell him a car," Knight said. "He test drove it, but didn't come through with the deal we had arranged. That's all it was."



Chris Spielman
http://www.toledoblade.com/apps/pbcs.dll/article?AID=/20041110/SPORTS16/411100387/-1/SPORTS
Former Buckeyes star linebacker Chris Spielman, who hosts a radio talk show in Columbus, said he was saddened by Mr. Clarett's allegations.

"I would be absolutely floored and shocked if any of it is true," Mr. Spielman said.

"I think they ought to give Maurice Clarett a lie detector test."



Vince Peterson
http://www.tribune-chronicle.com/sports/story/1111202004_spt02burcham11.asp
Warren's Vince Peterson, who played for Tressel at YSU where he was a co-captain, expressed disappointment that such a charge would be leveled at his former coach.

"I've talked with several of his former players and everybody is feeling the same way about it. Nobody believes any of it.''

Peterson said he didn't put any stock into the accusations made by Clarett. "The only person his remarks are going to hurt is Maurice.

"Coach Tressel's integrity is going to hold up,'' said Peterson.



Vince Marrow
http://www.usatoday.com/sports/college/football/bigten/2004-11-09-clarett-osu_x.htm
"Do I have any doubts?" said Vince Marrow, Clarett's cousin and family spokesman. "I can't make no comment on that. ... As time goes on, all that stuff will come out. I'll just put it like that."

Said Marrow, "He's made some waves."
 
Upvote 0
He said ... they said - 11/11/04

11/11/04 Articles:

Troy Smith
http://www.centralohio.com/ohiostate/stories/20041111/football/1574393.html
"It was a shock to me as it was to my teammates," said quarterback Troy Smith, one of Clarett's closest friends at OSU. "It's sad to finally hear from him through some negative things."

Smith said he had no way of knowing if Clarett fabricated all of his allegations and was too busy preparing for Saturday's game to analyze the motivation behind the damaging comments.

"I haven't talked to (Clarett) in such a long time, I can't speak for him right now," Smith said. "When I was interacting with him, I couldn't speak for him then because he's sort of unpredictable in some situations.

"But I sit down sometimes and pray for him because you never know what can happen to somebody."



Simon Frasier
http://www.centralohio.com/ohiostate/stories/20041111/football/1574393.html
Defensive end Simon Fraser said he is totally oblivious to his teammates' mode of transportation.

"I get in my car and go home because I'm tired and hungry," he said. "I really never noticed anything out of the ordinary. I never noticed a jet plane landing in the Woody Hayes parking lot."



Dustin Fox
http://www.centralohio.com/ohiostate/stories/20041111/football/1574393.html

"I don't really know him as person to say much about him," senior cornerback Dustin Fox said when asked about Clarett and the rip job he's doing on Ohio State in this week's issue of ESPN The Magazine.

"He's almost like a legend because you don't see him often and you answer a lot of questions about him. He was only here for a year ... so it's kind of strange."

By recruiting Clarett, Ohio State traded one year of dominance for three years (and counting) of disruption.

Arguably the MVP of the 2002 national championship team, Clarett is now accusing Ohio State of setting him up with high-end cars, palm-greasing boosters, easy classes and bogus jobs in a bizarre attempt to clear his name with NFL owners and general mangers.

He claims coach Jim Tressel "sold me out" after the temptestuous tailback lied to NCAA investigators to cover up wrongdoing in the program. The investigation resulted in Clarett's banishment from the team before he played a down in 2003.

"It's a little disheartening, just because of the experiences I've had with coach Tressel, knowing him on a personal level and the way he treats his players," Fox said. "I could never imagine a situation where he would do that to myself or any player I know here."

If Clarett was receiving thousands of dollars in hand-outs from boosters, he apparently was running in different circles than the other Buckeyes.

"I'm so confused by it," said uber-kicker Mike Nugent, apparently willing to wait until he's in the NFL next year to cash in. "I have friends on other teams that will tell me about things they've heard happened in the past on their teams. They'll say, `Yeah, I bet a lot of that goes on at Ohio State.' I'm like, `Absolutely not.'"

Clarett makes it sound in the article as if his "free ride" at OSU meant more than just being on scholarship. He said Tressel arranged for loaner cars, including a Chevy Tahoe and Ford Expedition. When he got bored with one car, he'd move on to another.

"I noticed one or two different cars, but I'm one of those people so in the dark, I don't know much about (Clarett's) family history," Nugent said. "It's not the first thing on my list. If I see a nice car outside (the Woody Hayes practice facility), it's not like, `OK, who's driving that car? I've got to find out how he got it.'

"If I work hard, maybe I can have something like that, maybe I can get to that point someday. But I just worry more about what I have to do and helping the team get better."



Ivan Douglas
http://www.dispatch.com/football/football.php?story=dispatch/2004/11/11/20041111-E1-00.html&chck=t
Ivan Douglas, a teammate of Clarett’s on the 2002 team, said he was among those who took advantage of the summer-job program.

"I did mostly landscaping jobs," said Douglas, an offensive tackle whose career was cut short by blood clots in his lungs. "The company I was with (Warwick’s Landscaping) is no longer there, but it was a pretty good job for me.

"All the stuff I’m hearing, I didn’t experience any of that. From my standpoint, those jobs were straight up. I worked my butt off. I made $10 an hour. It was decent."



Scott McMullen
http://www.dispatch.com/football/football.php?story=dispatch/2004/11/11/20041111-E1-00.html&chck=t
"The only thing I can say is that I wish I was in (Clarett’s) shoes," joked Scott McMullen, an Ohio State quarterback from 2000 to 2003. "I drove a Nissan Altima for five years. During the winter, I had to put plastic over my windows so it didn’t get too cold. I could have used some of that money."

He added, "I wouldn’t have taken it because it would have been a violation. In my five years, I never was offered any benefits."



Marco Cooper
http://www.dispatch.com/football/football.php?story=dispatch/2004/11/11/20041111-E1-00.html&chck=t
Cooper, who was suspended from the team in April 2002 after two arrests for drug possession, said he landed a summer job with M/I Homes in 2001 in which he did a little painting and a little landscaping. Emphasis on little.

Phone calls to M/I Homes yesterday were not returned.

"I had to be there. I had to be around. I might not have always been doing work," Cooper said, disputing some details of an ESPN The Magazine report that he had a bogus landscaping job, received furniture from a booster and borrowed cars from a Columbus dealership in exchange for signed Buckeyes memorabilia while he was a player.

In Cooper’s case, he said, a member of the football staff provided the contact, but it was his responsibility to follow up on it.

"I had to call them and get in touch with them. It was not, ‘Do you want to work?’ Basically, it’s initiative," Cooper said.



Robert Smith
http://sports.espn.go.com/ncf/news/story?id=1920711
"Absolutely I think that (Clarett getting paid by boosters) happened," he said. "I believe that it's happened. But there's a difference between fans providing it or members of the university. There's a huge distinction. I don't believe members of the university provided for him."

Robert Smith believes there has been booster-player financial interaction at Ohio State.

Why does Smith believe that Clarett is being truthful about the money?

Because Smith listened to teammates talking about the same sort of payments when Smith starred as a tailback in Columbus from 1990-92.

"I know players who played there who talked about it," he said. "It's not the kind of thing that was seen, but I know players I played with that talked about it."

Smith's description of the booster culture surrounding Ohio State's football program in the early 1990s fits with Clarett's statements about the current one. In the Nov. 22 issue of ESPN The Magazine, Clarett said before he left events where boosters were present, they would pull him aside. "When you'd leave, (the booster) sets you straight," Clarett said. "They say, 'You got any money in your pocket?' They make sure your money's straight."

Now a businessman living in Florida, Smith said that he knew which boosters gave players money. He would not comment on the booster names or the names of teammates he says accepted money.

But when asked if he heard about Ohio State teammates talking about, in his words, "$100 handshakes," Smith said: "Yeah."

Smith, who twice led the Buckeyes in rushing before playing nine seasons with the NFL's Minnesota Vikings, says a booster never offered him money. He believes that was because he was a pre-med major who once got into a dispute with a coach over high-level classes Smith took.

"I think that if players are looking for that kind of thing they can find it," he said. "You know what I mean? Some more than others. I really think, though, I had the kind of image at Ohio State where I may have been the whistle blower type. So that wasn't shoved in my hand."

Clarett said Tressel helped him get cars during his playing days by calling local dealerships. Smith said that he never witnessed anything like that when he was in school, however he heard similar stories from Buckeyes who played before him.

"I heard about car dealers, but that was like back in the '80s and even in the '70s actually," he said. "I didn't hear anything about that from current guys or guys that I played with."

Clarett also told the magazine that he would have been ineligible for Ohio State's 2002 national championship season if the football staff had not "aligned" him with academic advisors who simply had to maintain his eligibility by putting him in classes with handpicked teachers and by providing him with tutors who told him what to write for assignments.

Smith, 32, did not see or hear of any of those academic allegations during his time at Ohio State.

"The only thing I ever heard about -- I mean I heard easy A's from certain classes just because they were easy classes, and I heard it from regular students as well -- but I never heard about people getting tests or anything," he said. But, he added, "I'm sure there were some teachers that liked football players."

Ohio State athletic director Andy Geiger has denied Clarett's statements that Tressel or his staff provided illegal benefits for Clarett.

Smith said that he could see both sides of the argument.

"Yeah, we know this stuff goes on, but at the same time, like I said, I think that it's highly doubtful that the university was directly involved," he said

Smith said that he spoke with Clarett once, during the 2002 season, when Clarett wanted advice on handling the pressure as a player in Columbus. Clarett broke Smith's freshman rushing record that year. He also indicated he didn't believe Clarett's allegations would help a future career in the NFL.

"If he thinks it's going to help his standing with the NFL, he's got another thing coming," he said.



Tim Spencer
http://www.suntimes.com/output/campus/cst-spt-spencer11.html
Spencer, Clarett's position coach and an Ohio State assistant for 10 years, wanted to switch the focus to Bears running backs Thomas Jones and Anthony Thomas, but he was more willing to explore the topic.

''As an ex-Buckeye [player], you never want to see your school in trouble,'' Spencer said. ''I'm not saying they are. I don't know if what he said is true or not. That's for somebody else to try to decide or investigate or whatever they are going to do. I just move on.

''If some of that stuff is true, wouldn't I know about it? Well, I know what I know. If you know anything about a coach's schedule, you know we're in the dark about a lot of things. In terms of academics and stuff like that, we know as a coach how a guy is doing in class. ... But if you're asking me, wouldn't you be able to see if a guy has cars or stuff like that? We come out to practice like we do here, we go back in and it's dark when we leave, so we never know what's going on.''

Spencer reiterated that an investigation needs to determine whether Clarett's allegations in ESPN The Magazine are truthful. Spencer had hoped Clarett would regain his eligibility in 2003, when Clarett said coach Jim Tressel told him he had to maintain a 3.5 grade-point average and attend 6 a.m. workouts.

''I wanted to see him do everything right, and I wanted to see him come back and correct some of the things that had happened,'' Spencer said. ''I was on his side. There wasn't any Maurice's side and Tressel's side. It was about trying to get the kid right, get him in the right direction. There were stipulations, if I remember right, that Maurice had to do. Let's face it, he got himself into the academic situation.

''It's not for me to comment whether Maurice is credible or not. He's made some allegations and said some things. People need to do their due diligence and check those things out.''



Craig Krenzel
http://www.suntimes.com/output/campus/cst-spt-spencer11.html
Former Ohio State quarterback Craig Krenzel and running backs coach Tim Spencer tried to steer conversations toward what is going on with the Bears, but accusations by Maurice Clarett of widespread improprieties -- including academic fraud and cash gifts -- in the Buckeyes' football program reached Krenzel and Spencer on Wednesday at Halas Hall.

''I don't know what's going on with the whole situation,'' said Krenzel, who was Clarett's teammate on Ohio State's 2002 national-championship team. ''We never did know a whole lot of the information; we never wanted to. I'm here to talk about the Bears and Titans.''

When pressed on the matter with the suggestion that the Buckeyes could be stripped of their title, Krenzel didn't flinch.

''No. 1, I don't have time to think about it,'' he said. ''No. 2, I know there's been an investigation that took forever a long time ago, and they concluded nothing was to happen. I would be surprised if anything else was to change that.''



Will Allen
http://www.cleveland.com/sports/plaindealer/index.ssf?/base/sports/1100169146227680.xml
Former OSU players Craig Krenzel and Will Allen both said Wednesday they could not substantiate Clarett's charges.

Allen, who plays for the Tampa Bay Buccaneers, said "if anything did happen, I'm not sure. I walked the straight and narrow when I was there, which is why I'm not really worried about it. I got my degree. I got what I was there for."



Sam Maldonado
http://www.cleveland.com/sports/plaindealer/index.ssf?/base/sports/1100169146227680.xml
Former OSU player and current Maryland running back Sam Maldonado said his interview with ESPN was never intended to corroborate Clarett's charges.

"The interview that I did was with ESPN The Magazine and was about me," Maldonado said in a statement released by the school. "I said nothing about - and have nothing to say about - Maurice Clarett or anything that was mentioned in the article."

The Plain Dealer incorrectly reported Tuesday that Maldonado had been suspended at Maryland. He has not been suspended. That erroneous information, supplied by another news organization, was published due to reporter error.



Alex Boone
http://www.cleveland.com/sports/plaindealer/index.ssf?/base/sports/1100169146227680.xml
Clarett's accusations didn't hold much weight with three of the area's top high school prospects, two of whom have orally committed to play at OSU.

St. Edward All-Ohio senior offensive tackle Alex Boone said the controversy has not swayed his decision to sign a national letter of intent with the Buckeyes next February.

"Personally, I don't think it is true," said the 6-8, 320-pound Boone. "The Tressels are not the kind of people who would do something like that. . . . I'm a Buckeye, 100 percent."

http://ohiostate.scout.com/2/317826.html
In light of the current situation now, I asked Alex Boone if any of this stuff about Maurice Clarett and his new round of accusations against Jim Tressel concerns him in any way.

“It bothers me because I think it’s all false,” Boone said. “I think that Coach Tressel has way too much integrity to do that and I could never see him doing that. When I first heard it, the first thing that came to my mind was BS. Some people say it is (true) and some people say it isn’t but we’ll never know. But the fact that he would call somebody out like Coach Tressel and say that, I think that’s very disrespectful. I think Coach Tressel is probably one of the best guys that I know and I think he has way too much integrity to do something like that.”

Is there any scenario surrounding the Clarett allegations that would make him rethink his decision to attend Ohio State at all?

“Nothing would make me rethink my decision,” he said. “I’m 100 percent and I’ll always be no matter what happens. Some people are saying, ‘Well what happens if they have to forfeit a year?’ Whatever, then they do that. There’s no way I’m changing my mind, ever.”



Thom McDaniels
http://www.ohio.com/mld/ohio/sports/10152651.htm
His lack of credibility might be OSU's best defense. The talented Clarett has a history of making mistakes and blaming others. ``A victim of circumstances that he helped create.'' That's how Clarett's high school coach Thom McDaniels, of Warren Harding, so succinctly phrased it a year ago.

http://www.zwire.com/site/news.cfm?newsid=13340633&BRD=1699&PAG=461&dept_id=46370&rfi=6
Anyway, it happened somewhere. Maurice Clarett changed. And those left in his old life wonder where he went -- and where he went wrong.
''This isn't the one I know,'' said Thom McDaniels, his old high school coach at Warren Harding. ''I don't know who his counselor is or who his advisors are, but if they think this is a good thing for him to do, then they're stupid.''

http://www.daytondailynews.com/sports/content/sports/osu/daily/1111osufb.html
''I'm hurt, because this is not the way I would want him to behave,'' McDaniels said. ''But apparently it's the way someone wants him to behave. They have his ear now, I don't. And I haven't had it for a long time. I feel bad for him, because this only further damages the kid.''

McDaniels doesn't even have to think about it. He believes Tressel.

''I have a better relationship with him than I have with Maurice, I can tell you that,'' McDaniels said. ''And I know him to be noble, honorable and a man of great character and integrity. He's at the top of the list of people I know in the business. Maurice has put his reputation (on the line) and challenged Jim's with his own. And who's going to win that matchup? That seems foolish.''



Jim Brown
http://www.ohio.com/mld/ohio/sports/10152611.htm
Jim Brown considers Maurice Clarett a friend, but the legendary Browns running back admits to being out of touch with the latest allegations made by the former Ohio State tailback.

Brown said Wednesday he has not spoken to Clarett in three weeks and offered him no advice on whether to talk to reporters from ESPN The Magazine.

``I have no idea what all of this is about,'' Brown said. ``I am Maurice's friend, but I don't keep daily tabs on him.''

Brown said he had not read the ESPN The Magazine story in which Clarett accuses OSU coach Jim Tressel and members of his staff of arranging improper benefits such as loaner cars and no-show summer jobs. Clarett also charges the university with academic fraud and says he took thousands of dollars from boosters connected to the coaching staff.



Ray Isaac
http://www.daytondailynews.com/sports/content/sports/osu/daily/1111arch.html
Tressel has a sterling reputation among OSU alumni, fans and the high school coaches who send him talent. Dealing with the hundreds of players he does, there are bound to be some disgruntled charges — ESPN has four other former Bucks making claims — and Tressel has faced the failure of a primary player before. At Youngstown State, his star quarterback Ray Isaac — who, like Clarett, was said to be closer to the coach than any other player — ran into trouble because he got money, cars and grades he wasn't supposed to get.

Last year, Isaac — like Clarett now — claimed he didn't tell investigators the scope of the problems in order to spare the coach. "If I told everything," Isaac told the Dayton Daily News, "Youngstown State would have gotten the death penalty."


http://www.daytondailynews.com/sports/content/sports/osu/daily/1111osufb.html
Ray Isaac, the quarterback on the 1991 Youngstown State team that won the I-AA national championship, admits to taking more than $10,000 and several cars from Mickey Monus, a former YSU board of trustees president who is now serving a lengthy prison sentence for fraud and embezzlement.

The allegations first arose in 1994, when the NCAA urged Youngstown State to do an in-house inspection. It did, but turned up nothing. In 1998, the case exploded and all the details came out.

But conveniently enough, by then it was beyond the NCAA's four-year statute of limitations. The school self-imposed a number of penalties, the NCAA commended its thoroughness and the school was allowed to keep its national championship.

In an interview with the Dayton Daily News last year, Isaac said Tressel ''never, ever'' knew about the benefits and called Tressel his best friend in the whole world.

''Mickey assured me Tressel wouldn't find out and I don't think he did,'' Isaac said last year. ''I didn't stick it in his face.''



Steve Snapp
http://www.daytondailynews.com/sports/content/sports/osu/daily/1111osufb.html
"(Compliance director) Heather Lyke made a courtesy call to them to make sure they were aware of it," Snapp said. "They seemed to think there was nothing new here.

"The NCAA knows most of it was a rehash of things they've already investigated."

An NCAA spokesman declined to comment.



Mike Vrabel
http://www.boston.com/sports/articles/2004/11/11/against_clarett_vrabel_lines_up_alongside_osu/
Which is why Maurice Clarett's recent claims that he accepted money, cars, bogus jobs, and was involved in other improprieties that could get coach Jim Tressel and Ohio State in a lot of trouble with the NCAA if they're shown to be correct, has left a bad taste in Vrabel's mouth concerning the running back, who led the Buckeyes to the national championship in 2002.

"That's a tough situation," Vrabel said yesterday. "You look at what went on. It throws everything off of him and back on the university, and the university now has to go back and defend themselves again after they just did it with the whole NCAA investigation. Anybody can make a claim. Now they have to go back and open all their stuff up at a time when their focus is trying to get their season turned around."

"It was a [expletive] move," Vrabel said of Clarett's timing. "Those guys [current Ohio State players] could care less about Maurice Clarett. They've moved on. Yeah, if he was on the team he'd probably be helping them."

Clarett's possible motive?

"He's trying to figure out what GMs and owners and coaches think about him in this league. They don't care if you took money or cars, if you can help them win and they think you can stay out of trouble, there are organizations who could care less about this. If you can help them win, that's what they're looking for.

"To make a comment that, `I'm just trying to come clean with the owners and general managers that are making the decisions on draft day,' those guys don't care if you were driving a loaner Expedition or a Hummer. I feel bad because nobody wins in situations like these. It's frustrating."

Vrabel is active in the university community and spends time in Columbus, Ohio, in the offseason. He has become a fan of Tressel, and feels the coach doesn't deserve the heat he is getting because of Clarett's allegations.

"I know Jim Tressel and he's a stand-up man," said Vrabel. "He's a man with a lot of faith, a good Christian man. This is the last thing he needs during the season when he's trying to get a young team that lost three Big Ten games in a row. Now, it gets the lawyers and the university lawyers involved again. It's a big distraction for them."

"[Clarett] thinks they sold him out and he told Andy [Geiger, the athletic director] that he vowed, `I'll get back at you.' [Clarett] stands to make nothing off of this, while the university stands to lose players, eligibility, bowl game appearances, and everything that Ohio State has stood for over the years."

Vrabel said Ohio State has always been very conscious of its image, and the way players and coaches conduct themselves on and off the field. And Vrabel hates to see that image tarnished.

"I think the NCAA is coming along a little bit where you can help the player out where you can give a kid a meal," Vrabel said. "You can have a casual dinner with a booster. To sit there and say, `Yeah I gave the kid $1,000,' and to have a player say, `I took $1,000,' that's kind of crazy.

"It's really too bad. Like I said, nothing is gained from this. I feel bad for the kids there and having to see this stuff opened up again."
 
Upvote 0
He said ... they said - 11/12/04

11/12/04 Articles:

M/I Real Estate
http://www.dispatch.com/football/football.php?story=dispatch/2004/11/12/20041112-D1-04.html
Former Ohio State tailback Maurice Clarett worked briefly for a Columbus real estate company in the summer of 2002 but wasn’t paid for work he didn’t do, a company official said.

"Clarett worked like a day or two . . . and when the NCAA investigated before, we were cleared of any wrongdoing," said an official of Columbus based M/I Real Estate Co., who gave the information only on condition that his name would not be used.

(Marco) Cooper, who no longer plays for OSU, worked fewer than 40 hours at M/I Real Estate Co., the company said, adding that Clarett put in even less time.

"He (Cooper) worked sporadic hours at a lower hourly rate than full-time personnel, and only got paid when he worked," Brett Kaufman, executive vice president of M/I Real Estate, said in a statement issued yesterday.

"There was absolutely no bogus pay nor illegal benefits for Cooper or any other OSU athlete who ever worked with



Michael "Mickey" Monus / Ray Isaac / Jim Tressel
http://www.thelantern.com/news/2004/11/12/Sports/Clarett.Accusations.Find.New.Support-803161.shtml
Two separate articles on ESPN.com spotlight two former players: ex-OSU running back Robert Smith and former YSU quarterback Ray Isaac.

Isaac, who quarterbacked Tressel's 1991 National Championship team, discussed his time under Tressel. He said that Tressel introduced him to boosters who provided him with money and cars - allegations strikingly similar to ones made by Clarett this week.

Isaac took money from booster Michael "Mickey" Monus, chairman of the university's board of trustees and chief executive officer of the Phar-Mor discount drugstore chain. According to the article, Isaac made somewhere around $10,000 and had the use of various cars during his football career.

"I got a call from Mr. Tressel," Monus told a jury while on trial for corporate fraud crimes. "I believe the call was that he wanted me to be introduced to (Isaac) and to work out some kind of job for him."

Tressel reportedly denied knowing about any improper benefits his players earned while playing for him at YSU, as he has done at OSU. The NCAA imposed minor scholarship cuts on YSU after the institution admitted to a "lack of institutional control," according to ESPN.

The former quarterback had a chance to testify against Monus in court, and called Tressel for advice. Upon starting to tell him what he knew, Tressel quickly cut him off.

"I don't want to know what you know," Tressel told Isaac. "Just tell them the truth."



Maurice Hall
http://www.thelantern.com/news/2004/11/12/Sports/Clarett.Accusations.Find.New.Support-803161.shtml
"I don't know what his motive is for the things that he is saying, but we're just trying to stay focused on our team," senior running back Maurice Hall said.



Vince Marrow (Maurice's Cousin)
http://www.daytondailynews.com/sports/content/sports/osu/daily/1112osuside.html
But Vince Marrow, who had a brief career in the NFL and has spent much time by Clarett's side, admits the controversial star drove high-end vehicles without having to pay for them while leading the Buckeyes to the 2002 national title.

"I don't know where he got them from," Marrow said. "When I'd see him with cars, I'd ask the question, 'Man, where did these cars come from?' But he'd only have them for like two or three days.

"My speculation is ? even a regular person, if somebody thinks you're going to buy a car for them, they let you test drive it for a couple days."

Tressel has denied the allegations. And Marrow has doubts about Clarett's version.

"I've known coach Tressel for 18 years," Marrow said. "Coach Tressel is the first guy, when I was at Youngstown State playing basketball, to introduce me to the Fellowship of Christian Athletes. I've always known he was a pretty upright guy. The guy that I know, it (would be) just shocking to me" if the allegations were true.

Marrow said he saw Clarett, who was raised in inner-city Youngstown, living above his means — but couldn't say how the former Buckeye star obtained the money.

"I have no idea," Marrow said. "It was shocking. Just the money, just all of that."

Marrow said he wasn't consulted before the story broke. Most of the advice the player is getting now comes from his mother, Michelle.

"Michelle has basically total control with what Maurice does," Marrow said. "So, whatever Maurice did, I know his mom was 100 percent behind it.

"I was a little shocked. (But) I understand Maurice. He was very hurt with what happened at Ohio State."



Andy Groom
http://www.tribune-chronicle.com/sports/story/1112202004_spt03Buckeyes12.asp
Former Buckeyes Calvin Murray, Mike Sensibaugh and Andy Groom were at at DiVieste's Banquet Center in Howland Wednesday night to talk about the Ohio State-Michigan rivalry in an annual event called "The Game'' put on by the Warren Sports Hall of Fame. But all the three were bombarded with were questions about the embattled tailback.

"I've backed the kid in a lot of things throughout his career, but I am not going to back him on this one,'' said Groom, a former Clarett teammate and punter for Ohio State's 2002 national championship team. "He has lost a lot of respect. He has lost my respect. And all I have to say is that coach Tressel is one of the best men I've ever met in my life and I will back Tressel on anything involving this.''

The one thing that the three players agreed is that if something like this did happen, Jim Tressel was not aware of it.

"If something happened outside of the coaches, with a booster, there is no way for a coach, or any coach or (Ohio State athletic director) Andy Geiger ... they can't babysit every player every time," Groom said. "You can go to any college in America and find something like this. There is always going to be someone slipping someone money and it has nothing to do with Ohio State players and Ohio State coaches. Whatever Maurice Clarett is saying right now I think it is totally bogus and it is just a way to get back at Ohio State. He thinks they went against him and I don't see it. ''



Calvin Murray
http://www.tribune-chronicle.com/sports/story/1112202004_spt03Buckeyes12.asp
Former Buckeyes Calvin Murray, Mike Sensibaugh and Andy Groom were at at DiVieste's Banquet Center in Howland Wednesday night to talk about the Ohio State-Michigan rivalry in an annual event called "The Game'' put on by the Warren Sports Hall of Fame. But all the three were bombarded with were questions about the embattled tailback.

Murray and Sensibaugh said they do not really know what to think about the whole situation but they believe that Clarett is going about this the wrong way.

"I really for bad for Maurice Clarett and I feel bad for the university," Murray said. "We're a big family and there are some things that need to be kept in the house. And if he would have listened to the older guys, like some of the guys like myself and what some other players have been through he could have saved himself a whole lot of angst."

The one thing that the three players agreed is that if something like this did happen, Jim Tressel was not aware of it.

"I really believe coach Tressel is a good guy and he is a man who is trying to do the right things," Murray said. "He tried to give Maurice a chance to turn his life around and give him an opportunity. And for him to put this out there and put this all on him, coach Tressel is handling it the best way and not to speak negative of him."

Murray says the problem was Clarett and his inability to adapt to the traditions of Ohio State and the responsibility that comes with being a college athlete.

"I met him in passing, but he really did not seem like he wanted to have a conversation,'' Murray said. "He does not realize that there is a whole lot of tradition and a whole lot of people who are being hurt by this whole situation. It is just bringing things out that are in our house and certain things need to stay in our house.''

Murray also believes that not only is Clarett wasting his breath with these allegations, but more importantly his talent and integrity.

"People would have respected him and he would be just like what Ben (Roethlisberger) is now for the Steelers,'' Murray said. "He just threw away millions and he does not realize that he has caused a lot of pain to a lot of people. I wish he would not go this route.

"I just really hope the boy would just stop and it and let's move on," Murray said. "It's time to go on with our lives."



Mike Sensibaugh
http://www.tribune-chronicle.com/sports/story/1112202004_spt03Buckeyes12.asp
Former Buckeyes Calvin Murray, Mike Sensibaugh and Andy Groom were at at DiVieste's Banquet Center in Howland Wednesday night to talk about the Ohio State-Michigan rivalry in an annual event called "The Game'' put on by the Warren Sports Hall of Fame. But all the three were bombarded with were questions about the embattled tailback.

Murray and Sensibaugh said they do not really know what to think about the whole situation but they believe that Clarett is going about this the wrong way.

"I've never met him (Clarett) and I don't know if I want to meet him," Sensibaugh said. "It seems like something went wrong from the beginning and it's a tough situation for the kid and for the university. How much is true and how much isn't, I have no clue."

The one thing that the three players agreed is that if something like this did happen, Jim Tressel was not aware of it.

"I can't see someone jeopardizing themselves that way,'' he said. "Coach Tressel was a breath of fresh air for the alumni. From the days after Earle Bruce was there and when Tressel came in, he let the past players know that they were welcome and they were encouraged for their input and it made us feel like we were part of the program again.''



Bill Polian
http://slam.canoe.ca/Slam/Football/NFL/2004/10/02/653445-ap.html
But it really won't affect his draft status drastically because he doesn't appear to have much.

"I think he's marginal anyway," Indianapolis general manager Bill Polian said this week. "This is a character issue and that will be looked into with great depth. In the long run, he's got to prove he can play."



Gil Brandt
http://slam.canoe.ca/Slam/Football/NFL/2004/10/02/653445-ap.html
All that did for Clarett was to raise eyebrows among NFL people, already wary of players whose conduct has been out of the ordinary. Look no further than Ricky Williams for that.

"The only fallout is that teams will look more closely at character issues and that's not going to help the young man," said Gil Brandt, the NFL's scouting consultant.



Andy Geiger
http://www.nbc4i.com/sports/3915443/detail.html
Geiger said neither event was something he looked forward to.

"I've been the college athletic director at five universities for 33 years, all distinguished and fine universities," Geiger told NBC 4. "And until the last two years, I have not experienced widespread trouble like this. There had been instances of times when I wish things had been better, but this type of thing is a new one for me and it's not enjoyable."

Geiger said both O'Brien and Clarett signed affidavits that they understood the rules and, in fact, all student-athletes and anyone working in the athletic department signs the affidavits. Geiger said that means the school does not carry the entire burden.

"Compliance is, must be and should be a shared responsibility," Geiger said.

Geiger said the athletic department has monitors and provisions in place to make sure rules and regulations are followed. He said things can go wrong when the human element is included.

Geiger said he is concerned about the perception of Ohio State through all of these incidents. He also said he feels bad that some of the success in other sports gets overshadowed by the negative incidents.
 
Last edited:
Upvote 0
The Maurice Clarett Saga Unfolds

ESPN Article #12.

11/12/04
Barre hosted Clarett on his recruiting visit - ESPN FB

Friday, November 12, 2004
Barre hosted Clarett on his recruiting visit
By Seth Wickersham - ESPN The Magazine
*
B.J. Barre, a former Ohio State cornerback who was host to Maurice Clarett during the ex-tailback's recruiting trip, says that during his two years as a scholarship-athlete he was paid for doing little work, had tutors write papers for him and was enrolled -- without his knowledge -- into Ohio State's Office of Disability Services so that he could take tests with help and under no time limit.

Barre said he supported Clarett by speaking publicly about taking money from boosters and academic improprieties because "I understand what he's going through."

"I think everybody already knows it was kinda going on," he said. After reading Clarett's comments in the Nov. 22 issue of ESPN The Magazine, Barre said: "It wasn't nothing new to me."

Barre, who played in 10 games as a freshman at Ohio State in 2000, said that he worked construction on Ohio Stadium during the spring and early summer of 2001. He said he did not remember the name of the company that hired him. He said that "six or seven" other Ohio State players did it with him but declined to give their names.

"I worked construction on the stadium," Barre said. "I pretty much gathered up and hung out with the boys, went to go get something to eat and kinda just, you know, I guess what they call work, but we really didn't do too much work."

Barre said the most work he ever did was push a broom. Clarett and former Buckeye Curtis Crosby told ESPN The Magazine about similar no-work/high-pay jobs.

"It would vary," Barre said. "Depends on how much we showed up. If you show up four times a week, you might get $800, $900, almost $1,000, depending on how much you showed up."

Barre, now 23 and playing with the Arena Football League's Chicago Rush, said his tutors often did his classwork for him.

"When I was there, I kinda had a couple of tutors who wrote a couple of papers for me and stuff like that and help me out more than they were supposed to," he said.


Although he says he does not have any sort of learning problems, he was allowed to take tests under guidelines for students with learning disabilities.

"It was a program where I'd go to a different building to take my test. I would leave class to take my test," he said. "Sometimes the teacher would help me with the test, like the tutor would read it to me or whatever to help me with the test."

Barre echoed Clarett and other former Buckeyes Sammy Maldonado and LeAndre Boone, who said their schedules were stacked with classes friendly to athletes. The first that popped into Barre's mind was the same African-American studies class Clarett took. Clarett said he almost never attended that class and when he did it was not difficult to cheat.

Did certain Ohio State teachers give football players an easy ride?

"I don't wanna say easy ride," Barre said, "but I guess show favoritism."

Barre said that he did not go to his African-American studies class yet received points for attendance.

Like several other former players who spoke to ESPN, Barre said his academic adviser picked his class schedule.

"You have advisers. It's not really you doing it. You don't even really have to pick your schedule out," he said.

Barre said he felt he fell out of favor with the Buckeyes coaching staff and after that thought his academic advisers stacked his classes to a level where he couldn't avoid flunking out. During the fall semester of 2001, he registered with 21 credit hours -- a normal load is 12 to 14 hours; included were difficult courses, such as upper-level physics.

"I think guys they'd want outta there, they'd try to load 'em up with a lot of classes, knowing they're already in academic trouble," he said. "And load 'em up with, ya know what I'm saying, really hard classes and push 'em out of there."

Barre doesn't know how he fell out of favor with Jim Tressel and other Ohio State coaches.

"That's the question I ask myself," he said.

Barre indicated boosters paid other OSU football players. He said he never saw money transfer hands, but he and other players were given credit cards with names other than their own. He also said he saw players driving around in numerous different cars.

"Yeah, I mean a guy don't just pop up with two and three cars a week, you know what I'm saying?" he said. "Switching cars like that because, like you said, we're college athletes. We don't get paid for playing football. So it's kinda hard for a guy to just pop up with two or three cars a month or something like that. We don't have the money to pay for it."

Barre, who went to Whitmer High in Toledo, flunked out of Ohio State in 2002 and continued playing football at Pasadena City College in California, where he earned his associate's degree. He was host to Clarett when the noted high school star made his recruiting visit to Columbus in 2001.

"He was a pretty cool guy," he said.

Ohio State associate athletics director for communications Steve Snapp said the university would have no comment on Barre's allegations.
 
Last edited:
Upvote 0
I think guys they'd want outta there, they'd try to load 'em up with a lot of classes, knowing they're already in academic trouble," he said. "And load 'em up with, ya know what I'm saying, really hard classes and push 'em out of there."

He had easy classes because he was a football player. In a class with the learning disabled.
And still flunked out?! Give me a break. Anothe really credible witness. :slappy:
 
Upvote 0
He said ... they said - 11/13 & 14/04

11/13/04 Articles:

Jim Tressel
http://www.ohio.com/mld/ohio/sports/10172167.htm
And all Tressel wants to talk about is football, particularly this afternoon's game at Purdue.

``What I want to do right now is get ready for Purdue and take care of things as they need to be,'' Tressel said Tuesday at his weekly news conference when pressed on the Clarett matter.

A day later in a meeting with reporters, the coach was asked if he would have done anything different in handling Clarett or in the future with other players to keep his reputation from being questioned.

``In regards to Purdue?'' Tressel was quoted as saying. ``No. We were working on Purdue.''

According to a report on ESPN.com, another former Buckeye, cornerback B.J. Barre, claims he was given a no-work job and had tutors write papers for him. Barre played in 10 games in the 2000 season.

An OSU spokesman would not comment to ESPN.com on Barre's accusations.

``Obviously, there's a time sequence in everything, and we'll take care of that,'' Tressel said.



Mark Rea
http://ohiostate.rivals.com/content.asp?CID=354221
aurorabuckeye: Whatís the deal with Herbstreit? Is he trying to bend over backward to seem impartial? Or does he have an ax to grind with JT? Or what?
Rea: He has to be impartial if heís truly going to be a member of the media. He struggles with that occasionally. However, I have to say that he needs to step up and tell what he knows from his days at OSU. Robert Smith said there were ì$100 handshakesî during his time with the Buckeyes. Herbstreit was there at the same time. Did he see that or is he reluctant to refute what a former teammate and buddy has to say? Sorry, Kirk, but you donít get to play both sides.

LaserBuck84: Iíd like to know your journalistic impressions of the tactics, the sources Ö does this make sense to you from a journalism perspective for an organization (ESPN) owned by ABC, which has historically and a VERY strong relationship with the B10/Ohio State? Their "non-credible" sources have now recently found God and are honest, and want to help society? All I can say is that ESPN/ABC must be pretty confident in what they have "in hand" to put the history and relationship at peril, by running with the words of a few "special" characters. Otherwise, they need to feel some supreme retaliation and pain from the Big Ten and Ohio State. Your take on the journalism aspect?
Rea: First of all, ABC can plead that it has nothing to do with the way ESPN runs its business and they would have a point. The two are separate entities under the same umbrella, but the Big Ten and Ohio State would be extremely foolish to make this an issue with ABC. The TV money is simply too great. From a journalistic standpoint, the way the story was done ñ and continues to be championed ñ sickens me and Iíll leave it at that Ö for now.

rcarpenter62: What do you mean ìleave it at that, for now?î As you can see, I am very paranoid regarding the entire subject.
Rea: I simply meant that I have already written a column for BSB print that pretty much rips ESPN and its reporters a new you-know-what





11/14/04 Articles:

Andy Geiger
http://www.sportsline.com/collegefootball/story/7888079
COLUMBUS, Ohio -- Ohio State athletic director Andy Geiger is happy the NCAA is coming to the university's campus Monday to investigate allegations made by former Buckeyes star Maurice Clarett. Advertisement

"I hope there is the most thorough investigation in the history of intercollegiate athletics, because this is so bogus I can't even characterize it," Geiger told reporters after Saturday's loss at Purdue.

"The allegations are so sweeping, so over the top that we are going to be forced to spend huge resources, so much time and energy and effort, to try and get this right," Geiger said. "This isn't going to be solved by the Michigan game or by (the time of) a bowl game. It will take months, I imagine."

http://www.dispatch.com/football/football.php?story=dispatch/2004/11/14/20041114-E1-01.html
Though athletics director Andy Geiger said yesterday he welcomes back the NCAA, he also took the opportunity to ridicule ESPN for sloppy reporting.

"It’s just throw enough stuff out and something might stick," Geiger said, before offering a game plan for other media. "You’re going to have to get out on the streets and find how these kinds of things happen. If thousands of dollars are being spent by boosters on our program, go find it. I can’t find it. You go find it.

"We’ve all been a part of nurturing it and bringing it along. We’ve been cooperative," he said. "We invite (ESPN) in to tell us what jerks we are. It’s entertainment and they’re using the people who provide them with their wealth in a very bizarre way."

The NCAA’s first investigation found that Clarett violated NCAA bylaws and resulted in his suspension for the 2003 season.

"They wanted to come (back) and we wanted them to come. We want as vigorous an investigation as we can get," Geiger said after the Buckeyes’ 24-17 loss to Purdue.

Geiger said he will look into whether Ohio State can, or should, disclose student records to clear its name. He also said it will take a while.

"They’re going to start a new investigation. It takes months. This isn’t going to be solved by the Michigan game or by the bowl game. It might not be solved this year because it’s so sweeping and so over the top that we are going to be forced to spend huge resources, time and energy and effort to try to get it right," he said.

Additionally, Barre claimed that he was placed in Ohio State’s disability services program without his knowledge.

Geiger dismissed Barre’s allegations, saying only the student, not the university, can place himself in the disability program.

"When do we get a story out of them that’s vetted?" said Geiger, explaining that the stories have been sloppy with their background checks and fact-checking

http://www.toledoblade.com/apps/pbcs.dll/article?AID=/20041114/SPORTS16/411140435/-1/SPORTS
"We've got to start over, as far as I'm concerned, " Geiger said after OSU's 24-17 loss at Purdue.

The visit by the NCAA, supposedly at the invitation of OSU, is in response to accusations made by former Buckeye running back Maurice Clarett, whose comments in an article posted last week on ESPN.com alleged academic fraud and illegal benefits, some of which he laid at the feet of coach Jim Tressel.

Geiger indicated Ohio State would also begin a new probe of its own, independent of anything done by the NCAA.

"The allegations are so sweeping, so over the top that we are going to be forced to spend huge resources, so much time and energy and effort, to try and get this right," Geiger said.

"This isn't going to be solved by the Michigan game, or by [the time of] a bowl game.

"It will take months, I imagine."

Geiger has stated that OSU and the NCAA conducted investigations of similar allegations made before and after a Sept. 10, 2003 decision to suspend Clarett for the 2003 season because the star running back, who helped lead the Buckeyes to the 2002 national championship, had reportedly accepted special benefits from a family friend and misled NCAA investigators.

Geiger reiterated that Ohio State and its staff escaped any culpability then, and said yesterday he is confident any new investigations will produce the same result.

"Because [the allegations] are so bizarre, I'm more confident," he said.

"But I want somebody else to say that besides me. I think it is very, very important this is exposed for what it is.

"I have a report this thick on Maurice Clarett," Geiger continued, holding one hand about 12 inches above the other.

"I want to find out what we can tell, what is [a] protected student record and what is not.

"The lawyers will let us know what we can say and what we can't say."

http://www.morningjournal.com/site/news.cfm?newsid=13361229&BRD=1699&PAG=461&dept_id=46370&rfi=6
Athletic Director Andy Geiger said during yesterday's 24-17 loss at Purdue that he has invited the NCAA back to re-examine the situation, but stopped short of calling it an investigation.

''The NCAA will have a representative at Ohio State on Monday,'' Geiger said. ''And we welcome them. We invited them. We asked them to please participate.''

Geiger had not read the story and wouldn't comment on Barre.
''I don't remember the kid,'' Geiger said. ''If I say anything and defend anything, it raises him to an elevation that is unwarranted.''

Curtis Crosby, another relatively unknown former Buckeye, also corroborated the claims of both Clarett and Barre. Crosby was on the team in 2000.

''If ESPN, in their -- whatever they're doing -- thinks it's honorable to rely only on colossal failures, then I have no use for ESPN,'' Geiger said. ''I don't anyway.''



Rob Sims
http://www.cleveland.com/sports/plaindealer/bud_shaw/index.ssf?/base/sports/1100428301286472.xml

The week's headlines were one big softball lobbed to the good farm folk of Indiana, who took David Ortiz-sized swings.

"Coach Tressel, I can use a car" one sign read. Next to those words: "2002 National Cheaters." "Mom send money" was another, with "Mom" crossed out and "OSU boosters" inserted.

"It always hurts when somebody is looking at your university like you've done something wrong," said Sims.



Troy Smith, A.J. Hawk, Bobby Carpenter, Rob Sims
http://news.enquirer.com/apps/pbcs.dll/article?AID=/20041114/SPT01/411140398/1063/SPT
"Life is filled with trials and tribulations," said quarterback Troy Smith. "It is all how you respond."

They claimed Saturday not to have been distracted. Purdue beat them. Orton beat them. Turnovers beat them.
Not Clarett.

"We have no idea about any of that stuff. We know what we have to do to win games. That's what we focus on," said linebacker A.J. Hawk.

"Nothing they can say or do is going to affect me or really anyone else," linebacker Bobby Carpenter said. "So I don't think it bothered us.

"We sat down as a team and talked about it. Do the best we can this week to keep (the coaches') stress level down. They're kind of on edge right now.

"I've only seen the best out of Coach Tressel that I could possibly see. The coaches are all high quality people. That's why my mother wanted me to come here."

But it can't be easy inside Ohio State's program right now, with so much noise outside.

"Nothing comes easy," Sims said, "when you're a Buckeye."

Except grades, according to Maurice Clarett.
 
Last edited:
Upvote 0
The Maurice Clarett Saga Unfolds

ESPN Article #13. This article is a recompilation/repackaging of information and news from sources outside of ESPN. What's interesting to note is the quotes from Andy Geiger that ESPN choose to use. They only use the ones that seem to support their position that OSU needs to be investigated by the NCAA, while conveniently leaving out the comments critical of ESPN. All comments were in the Columbus Dispatch, a source ESPN lists in their article, yet only ones that favor ESPN seemed to make their story. The Dispatch story is listed (italics) and then the ESPN article follows:


http://www.dispatch.com/football/fo...1114-E1-01.html
Though athletics director Andy Geiger said yesterday he welcomes back the NCAA, he also took the opportunity to ridicule ESPN for sloppy reporting.

"It’s just throw enough stuff out and something might stick," Geiger said, before offering a game plan for other media. "You’re going to have to get out on the streets and find how these kinds of things happen. If thousands of dollars are being spent by boosters on our program, go find it. I can’t find it. You go find it.

"We’ve all been a part of nurturing it and bringing it along. We’ve been cooperative," he said. "We invite (ESPN) in to tell us what jerks we are. It’s entertainment and they’re using the people who provide them with their wealth in a very bizarre way."

The NCAA’s first investigation found that Clarett violated NCAA bylaws and resulted in his suspension for the 2003 season.

"They wanted to come (back) and we wanted them to come. We want as vigorous an investigation as we can get," Geiger said after the Buckeyes’ 24-17 loss to Purdue.

Geiger said he will look into whether Ohio State can, or should, disclose student records to clear its name. He also said it will take a while.

"They’re going to start a new investigation. It takes months. This isn’t going to be solved by the Michigan game or by the bowl game. It might not be solved this year because it’s so sweeping and so over the top that we are going to be forced to spend huge resources, time and energy and effort to try to get it right," he said.

Additionally, Barre claimed that he was placed in Ohio State’s disability services program without his knowledge.

Geiger dismissed Barre’s allegations, saying only the student, not the university, can place himself in the disability program.

"When do we get a story out of them that’s vetted?" said Geiger, explaining that the stories have been sloppy with their background checks and fact-checking




11/15/04
NCAA allows perk for D-I programs - ESPN FB

Monday, November 15, 2004
NCAA allows perk for D-I programs
ESPN.com news services

COLUMBUS, Ohio -- Sixty-four car dealers are enrolled in a program to give free cars to Ohio State coaches and athletic department staff, according to a Columbus Dispatch report.

The dealers provide 85 cars for Ohio State coaches, assistants, department workers, the wives of two coaches, and athletic director Andy Geiger in exchange for season tickets and other perks, according to a Dispatch story Sunday.

The newspaper's report comes on the heels of former Buckeye running back Maurice Clarett's accusing coach Jim Tressel, his staff and school boosters of arranging for him to get passing grades, car and thousands of dollars, including for bogus summer jobs. Clarett's claims, reported Tuesday by ESPN The Magazine on ESPN.com, have been corroborated by former Buckeyes players Marco Cooper, Curtis Crosby and B.J. Barre.

The university has denied their allegations.

NCAA spokeswoman Jennifer Kearns told the Dispatch that free-car programs for non-players do not violate Division I rules. The practice of providing coaches and school officials with vehicles is commonplace.

By invitation from Ohio State, the NCAA will have a representative on campus Monday to investigate allegations of improper benefits from Maurice Clarett and other former players, Geiger said Saturday.

"I hope there is the most thorough investigation in the history of intercollegiate athletics, because this is so bogus I can't even characterize it," Geiger told reporters during the Ohio State-Purdue game in West Lafayette, Ind.

"We welcome [the NCAA]. We invited them. We asked them to, please, participate."

Clarett said he got a free loaner car from a dealer recommended by Tressel, who gets cars there under the program. Dealers provide cars in exchange for access to season tickets and other perks, the Dispatch reported.

Geiger said Tressel did try to help Clarett buy a car through the dealership that leases cars to several Ohio State coaches and administrators. But Clarett and his mother did not meet with the dealer to make arrangements to buy the car, Geiger said, and the dealership came to Columbus several days later to repossess it.

Most of Clarett's charges were addressed as part of an NCAA probe that found the star running back -- a freshman at that time -- lied to investigators, leading to his suspension from the team he helped win the 2002 national championship.

Geiger said many of the accusations were found to be baseless in investigations by the NCAA and the university.

"The allegations are so sweeping, so over the top that we are going to be forced to spend huge resources, so much time and energy and effort, to try and get this right," Geiger said. "This isn't going to be solved by the Michigan game or by [the time of] a bowl game. It will take months, I imagine."
 
Last edited:
Upvote 0
He said ... they said - 11/15/04

11/15/04 Articles:

A.J. Hawk
http://www.newarkadvocate.com/news/stories/20041115/localnews/1595781.html
Linebacker A.J. Hawk doesn't believe the players are distracted by the Clarett situation. "Since I've been here, it seems like we have all these things going on off the field with the media," he said. "It doesn't matter to us. We know everything here is clean. I've never heard of half of those accusations. All the off-the-field (stuff) doesn't matter. We know what we have to do on the field."
 
Last edited:
Upvote 0
The Players - Mike Freeman

Mike Freeman - NYTimes / Indianapolis Star / Florida Times-Union
Mike Freeman broke the original story on Maurice Clarett for the New York Times. It turns out that Tom Friend (who broke the latest story on Maurice) also worked for the New York Times at the time as Freeman. Mike left the NY Times and went to the Indy Star, where he resigned for falsifying his resume/application. Mike now works for the Florida Times-Union where he has penned another article critical of OSU and the Buckeye Athletic Department.

Here is the article (by Mike Freeman) that started the whole Maurice Clarett saga. The header below (in italics) is from the NYTimes search engine and contains a correction they were obliged to run.

SPORTS DESK | July 13, 2003, Sunday

COLLEGES; When Values Collide: Clarett Got Unusual Aid in Ohio State Class
By MIKE FREEMAN (NYT) 2598 words
Late Edition - Final , Section 8 , Page 1 , Column 1

Correction: July 17, 2003, Thursday

A sports article on Sunday about accusations of academic impropriety involving an Ohio State football player, Maurice Clarett, misstated the location of Warren G. Harding High School, which he attended. It is Warren, Ohio, not Youngstown.



07/13/03
When Values Collide: Clarett Got Unusual Aid in Ohio State Class - New York Times FB

When Values Collide: Clarett Got Unusual Aid in Ohio State Class
By MIKE FREEMAN

COLUMBUS, Ohio - While only a freshman, Maurice Clarett emerged as a star tailback last fall and helped lead Ohio State to an undefeated season and the national championship. But Clarett's work in the classroom was not as assured as his moves on the football field, and he received some unusual assistance to pass one of his courses.

Clarett walked out of a midterm exam last fall in an introductory course in African-American and African studies without completing the exam. He never retook the midterm and did not take the final exam. But he passed the course after taking oral exams instead, an Ohio State official said.

The associate professor in charge of the course and the graduate student who oversaw Clarett's work agree on these details, but they differ markedly on the meaning of what happened.

The associate professor, Paulette Pierce, said she worked directly with Clarett and administered the two oral exams because she wanted to motivate him and because his lack of academic preparation required her to use unconventional means to test his knowledge.

The graduate student, who spoke on condition that she not be publicly identified, contended that Clarett had been given preferential treatment because he was a star football player. Two graduate assistants said they thought that Clarett had been the only one of about 80 students in the course who had been given oral exams by Pierce.

Whether Clarett received special consideration and whether the rules of the university or the National Collegiate Athletic Association were broken in the process are among a series of questions raised by the graduate student and other teaching assistants about the performance of athletes in that class and others at Ohio State.

The teaching assistant and Pierce, who is an associate professor of African-American and African studies, each said she suspected that academic tutors sometimes did homework for players. Pierce said several football players had told her tutors sometimes wrote papers for them, although she said she had no direct proof.

The teaching assistant said football players had forged the names of absent teammates on class attendance sheets.

These assertions, which resulted from interviews with more than a half-dozen teaching assistants and many professors and other officials at Ohio State over the past two months, illustrate the difficulty faced by universities with elite sports programs in trying to compete on the field with athletes who are sometimes not qualified to keep up in the classroom.

These demands can force professors to make difficult choices. Do they try to hold elite athletes to the same academic standards as nonathletes, knowing that some players are unlikely to succeed because of their academic backgrounds? Or do the professors use unorthodox methods to help struggling players remain eligible, even if those methods sometimes skirt university and N.C.A.A. regulations?

"I see some football players who probably should not be here, because their academic background is so wanting," Pierce said. "So I say to myself, `Do I keep shuttling them through the system, or do I try whatever it takes to get them to learn?' even if the methods I use may be seen as unorthodox."

Murray Sperber, a professor of English and American studies at Indiana University who has written about collegiate sports, said there had always been a conflict between academia and athletics.

"I think, clearly, in recent years, that conflict has worsened," he said. "Ohio State is an interesting situation. I've been told by faculty there that the message is, `No one is to criticize the sports program.' I think that is why, despite some of the problems there with athletes and academics, there have been so few public comments or criticisms from the faculty. Maybe now that is changing."

Clarett in the Classroom

Clarett quickly established himself as an extraordinary young player last September. The first true freshman to open the season as Ohio State's starting tailback, he rushed for nearly 500 yards and scored six touchdowns in his first three games.

Clarett's experiences in the classroom were more problematic. He fled from his midterm exam in African-American and African Studies 101 without completing it. "He looked at it and didn't know a thing," Pierce said.

Pierce decided soon afterward to work with Clarett, to motivate him and to find other ways of testing what he was learning. Pierce lectured to the entire class, and then once a week the group would break into smaller discussion sections led by graduate students, who work for the university as teaching assistants and who are generally responsible for grading the students.

Pierce insisted that her motivation for working with Clarett was empathy for a student who was unprepared for the rigors of college academics.

The teaching assistant, who was responsible for Clarett's discussion section, said he had begun the course full of enthusiasm. In a report written on Oct. 22, she described him in this way: "Great attitude; seems to enjoy lecture; not afraid to raise hand and participate in class."

But by early December, his attitude had changed, as she noted in a follow-up report: "Maurice is a mixed bag. Sometimes motivated, but will not put forth the effort it takes."

Pierce said Clarett had needed a lot of personal attention. "I don't think, at one point in the class, he was trying," she said. "When I started working more closely with Maurice, and paying more attention to him, he started to learn more."

Pierce decided to give Clarett an opportunity to make up the midterm by taking an oral test. His final exam was conducted the same way. Clarett passed both tests, a university official said.

But the teaching assistant said Clarett should have failed the course. Her records show he scored only 22 out of a possible 40 points on his quizzes and did not turn in the midterm or take the written final exam.

Because Clarett had said at one point that he had a reading disability, the teaching assistant said, he should have been evaluated by the university's Office for Disability Services.

She said that if the disability office had determined that Clarett had a disability, it could have given him permission for an oral exam; then the disability office, and not the professor, would have administered it.

Scott Lissner, the university's compliance officer for disability matters, agreed that that is generally the procedure if it is determined that a student has a disability. This is done to prevent abuse of the disability system, or even the appearance of abuse, Lissner said.

Another football player in a different section of the course was evaluated by the disability office and given permission to take oral exams, the teaching assistant said, and the disability office oversaw the tests. Clarett, however, never produced a permission slip to take oral exams, she said.

The teaching assistant questioned Pierce's motive and contended that she had ignored the university's rules and showed favoritism to Clarett.

But both Pierce and Kenneth Goings, chairman of the Department of African-American and African Studies, said vehemently that Pierce had acted properly.

Goings said it was within a professor's discretion to decide whether to administer oral exams. Pierce said she had given oral exams to nonathletes in the past and had allowed students to gain extra credit or make up missed assignments by painting, writing music or giving oral presentations.

Asked if Clarett had been evaluated by the disability office before taking the oral exams, Pierce and Goings separately said they could not remember.

Goings, whom the teaching assistant had sought out to discuss her concerns, attacked the teaching assistant's credibility, saying he found it difficult to believe her because she had a history of psychiatric problems and displayed what he called erratic behavior. Pierce, however, while not disputing the teaching assistant's accuracy, only disagreed with her conclusions.

The teaching assistant said she had endured bouts of depression, but she maintained that these had nothing to do with what transpired in the class.

Andy Geiger, Ohio State's athletic director, and David Frantz, a history professor and former member of the university's athletic council, which oversees matters involving student-athletes, also contended that a professor has complete discretion over how a student is taught and tested.

Frantz noted a paragraph in the course description written by Pierce: "I deeply appreciate that each student is a unique individual. If you have any special needs and/or interests that it would be helpful for me to know about please take the time to inform me. I may be able to make adjustments for you. I urge you to come to my office hours so that I can get to know you personally."

Clarett did not respond to e-mail messages, overnight letters and a note left at his apartment requesting an interview. University officials did not respond to a request to interview Clarett.

Pierce acknowledged that some of her teaching methods might be perceived as unconventional, but she denied that she was trying to "do whatever it took to pass them."

"The sports culture doesn't care about the whole human being," Pierce said. "The athletic department is more concerned about what they can get from these players. I have to find a hook to get the players interested, reel them in and then try to educate them. With some of the athletes, because of their learning problems, it takes some drastic steps."

Problem Is Wider

Clarett, Pierce and the graduate student met at one point during the fall quarter to discuss his struggles in the course. At the meeting, he provided examples of cheating by other athletes at Ohio State, the teaching assistant said.

He told them that some counselors who work with the Office of Student Athlete Support Services do schoolwork for the athletes, the assistant said. Clarett told them that sometimes a tutor provided two notebooks for a football player, she said: in one notebook, the tutor would have written the answers to homework; the other notebook would be blank. The player would copy the answers in his own handwriting in the second notebook, so nothing could be traced back to the tutor, she said.

Pierce said she recalled the meeting with Clarett but not specific details. She said the teaching assistant's account "sounded accurate to me."

Pierce said she had been told by football players in an unrelated conversation last fall that sometimes when they arrived for a meeting with a tutor, a completed term paper would be sitting on the desk and the tutor would be absent. The player would take the paper and leave, she said.

The teaching assistant said another football player had submitted work in her section of the course that she knew he could not have written. The student, Chris Vance, a wide receiver, submitted a sophisticated outline for a paper, and she said she assumed immediately that it had been written by someone else.

"It was too perfect," she said, "and up to that point his work was so poor. He never demonstrated the ability to put together such an outline."

In response to an e-mail message, Vance agreed to be interviewed and said he would telephone a reporter. He never called, however, and did not respond to additional e-mail messages.

"Some tutors are very good and some are not," Pierce said. "Some of the tutors make questionable decisions. Writing papers for the players, if that is true, is very questionable."

Pierce said she became so concerned about cheating on tests, by both athletes and nonathletes, that she deployed two teaching assistants to monitor a quiz closely in November.

"I needed to take that kind of action because of the level of cheating I suspected in the class," Pierce said. "I had the teaching assistants watch over the students like hawks. And yes, I felt some members of the football team were involved in the cheating. I cannot deny that."

Fallout From the Accusations

Vance was a regular contributor at wide receiver for the Buckeyes last season, playing in 10 games and starting in 1. In the African and African-American studies class, he scored a 55 on his midterm and a 35 on his final, had 11 unexcused absences and missed four of eight quizzes, the teaching assistant's records show.

"He is a senior in a freshman-level course," the teaching assistant wrote in a report on Vance. "The question is, why is he struggling?"

Vance failed the course, a university official said, and he struggled in many of his other classes, too. Yet he played in the Fiesta Bowl against Miami for the championship on Jan. 3. Elizabeth Conlisk, a spokeswoman for Ohio State, declined to discuss Vance's grades.

The teaching assistant said she had decided, with much trepidation, to meet with Goings, the department chairman, in April to discuss many of the questionable things that she believed had occurred in the class, particularly the struggles of Vance and Clarett.

"He called me a liar," said the assistant, who said she was dismissed from her teaching position after the meeting.

Goings said he did not believe the teaching assistant because of what he viewed as her erratic behavior and because she had a history of psychiatric problems. Goings said that after he questioned her credibility, she became belligerent and threatened to go public with her account.

Not long after meeting with Goings, the teaching assistant said, she underwent an emotional crisis. She was hospitalized for six weeks; she said she had been depressed and had suffered previously from depression.

She said, however, that her psychiatric problems had nothing to do with what occurred in the class, and she said she still believed Clarett had been given preferential treatment because he was a star player.

When Pierce was asked if she thought the teaching assistant was unreliable, she said, "No." Asked if she thought the assistant was exaggerating or inaccurate about the cheating that she said had taken place in the class, Pierce said, "I'd have to say no again."

The teaching assistant said she had returned to classes in late spring, but she is not taking classes now, a university official said. On June 27 she was evicted from a Columbus hotel where she had been staying. The teaching assistant had disappeared for several weeks, not returning telephone calls and e-mail messages from a reporter. [When reached July 12, the assistant said she had left Ohio State fearing reprisal for speaking out.]

Clarett is still in school, preparing for the football team's defense of its national title. He is widely considered a top Heisman Trophy candidate this fall. After a sterling career at Warren G. Harding High School in Warren, Ohio, and his breakthrough freshman season at Ohio State, Clarett is also thought likely to leave college for the National Football League before exhausting his four years of eligibility.

"To be honest, I don't think Maurice was interested in college," Paul Trina, athletic director at Harding High, said. "His dream is playing in the N.F.L. It always has been."
 
Last edited:
Upvote 0
The Players - Mike Freeman

Again, the header below is from the NYTimes search engine and contains a correction. This is the second article from Mike Freeman on allegations of academic misconduct involving Maurice Clarett.

SPORTS DESK | July 14, 2003, Monday

COLLEGES; Ohio State To Examine Special Help For Clarett
By MIKE FREEMAN (NYT) 727 words
Late Edition - Final , Section D , Page 1 , Column 1

Correction Appended
DISPLAYING FIRST 50 OF 727 WORDS - The president of Ohio State, Karen A. Holbrook, said the university would begin an investigation after a report that the star running back Maurice Clarett had received unusual aid in one of his classes as the football team marched toward a national championship last ... The New York Times reported...


Correction: July 16, 2003, Wednesday

A sports article on Monday about accusations of academic improprieties involving an Ohio State football player, Maurice Clarett, referred incorrectly in some copies to an Ohio newspaper that reported a meeting between him and N.C.A.A. officials. It is The Columbus Dispatch, not Post-



07/14/03
Ohio State to Examine Special Help for Clarett - New York Times FB

Ohio State to Examine Special Help for Clarett
By MIKE FREEMAN

The president of Ohio State, Karen A. Holbrook, said the university would investigate allegations of academic impropriety after a report that the star running back Maurice Clarett had received unusual aid in one of his classes as the football team marched toward a national championship last season.
Advertisement

The New York Times reported yesterday that Clarett, one of the premier college players in the country, had passed his African-American and African Studies class by taking two oral exams while the 80 or so other students took a more difficult written exam.

A teaching assistant, who spoke on the condition that she not be publicly identified, and the professor, Paulette Pierce, confirmed that Clarett had walked out of his midterm written exam. He did not retake it, nor did he take the written final exam.

Pierce, an associate professor, said she had given Clarett oral tests because his lack of academic preparation forced her to use unconventional teaching methods.

Pierce said she has given oral exams to other students in past years and she strongly denied allegations that Clarett received special consideration.

The athletic director, Andy Geiger, who attended a news conference yesterday with Holbrook and other university officials in Columbus, Ohio, said he was unaware that any N.C.A.A. rules had been broken. He also said that Clarett did not receive special consideration.

"There are no special considerations for student-athletes," he said.

Geiger and the university's incoming provost, Barbara Snyder, will lead the investigation, Holbrook said. It will look closely at the academic performance of athletes, at tutors who work closely with the athletic department and at the relationship between faculty members and athletes.

Clarett could not be reached for comment.

The teaching assistant said she had left Ohio State fearing reprisals from university officials and from fans of the football team.

Other news involving Clarett emerged yesterday, and it had nothing to do with academics. The Columbus Dispatch reported that Clarett recently had two meetings with N.C.A.A. officials who inquired about his finances and about possible dealings with his friend LeBron James, who was chosen as the N.B.A.'s No. 1 draft pick last month.

Geiger told the newspaper that he did not think the N.C.A.A.'s investigation would lead to Clarett's losing part of his eligibility for the upcoming season, but added: "That doesn't mean it won't change. As of now, he's fine."

The teaching assistant said one of the things that troubled her was the different treatment other football players had received during the course. She said that during a meeting with Pierce and Clarett, Clarett said he had a reading disability.

She said he should have been evaluated by the disability office in order to take his exams orally, and the office should have administered them if it was determined he had a disability.

Another football player, a reserve who was in a different section of the same class last fall, had a disability, the assistant said. He was evaluated by the disability office and provided with a permission slip to take the exams orally. They were administered by the disability office.

A third player, wide receiver Chris Vance, failed the class, according to a university official.

The teaching assistant said that Clarett was allowed to take the easiest path of the three because he was a star. Pierce and the chairman of the department, Kenneth Goings, vehemently denied the accusation.

The teaching assistant and Pierce also said that they were concerned about cheating in the class by athletes and nonathletes, and that academic tutors sometimes wrote papers for players, though Pierce stressed she had no direct proof.

In recent years, Ohio State has been trying to rebound from several embarrassing episodes involving its athletes and academic performance. In 2000, wide receiver Reggie Germany was declared ineligible for the Outback Bowl after recording a 0.0 grade point average for the fall quarter, according to U.S. News and World Report.

The most recent graduation rate data, covering the class that began the 1995-96 academic year, show that Ohio State ranked 10th out of the 11 universities in the Big Ten, graduating 60 percent of its athletes.

Only the University of Minnesota, at 54 percent, was worse.
 
Last edited:
Upvote 0
The Players - Mike Freeman

Here is an article from Editor and Publisher (an industry news outlet) that details Mike Freeman's firing/resigning from the Indianapolis Star for falsifying his resume/application.


01/12/04
Latest Credibility Scandal: Indy 'Star' Columnist Resigns - Editor and Publisher FB

Latest Credibility Scandal: Indy 'Star' Columnist Resigns
By Joe Strupp - Published: January 12, 2004

NEW YORK As newspapers grow more sensitive about their credibility, another scandal has hit the industry. Mike Freeman, the former New York Times sportswriter and newly named columnist at The Indianapolis Star, resigned his new position just days before he was to have started.

Admitting that he had lied on his application and on his resume about having graduated from college, Freeman quit the columnist post on Friday, according to Star Editor Dennis Ryerson. The paper had announced he was to have started today, Jan. 12.

"The Star is committed to operating with high ethical standards," Ryerson said in a note to readers posted Friday on the Star's Web site. "We recognize credibility issues have confronted our industry, and we want to be a leader in addressing those issues."

Sportspages.com first broke the story on Friday after Freeman told the Web site's editor, Rich Johnson, that he had left the paper. "I don't know how it came about, but he fessed up to us," Johnson told E&P Saturday. "He told me after he resigned."

In a statement that first appeared on the sports Web site, Freeman apologized for lying and said he had never before deceived an employer. "Late last month I left The New York Times to take a column position at The Indianapolis Star. While in the process of interviewing for the position, I filled out an application form and stated I was a graduate of the University of Delaware. I also, for the first time ever, stated this fact on my resume," the statement said, in part. "These were lies. I was at the university for four years but in fact did not graduate. This was a terrible and unforgivable manipulation of the facts and I have resigned from my newly accepted position as columnist for the Star. It was the only time I have told such falsehoods and no other deceptions have ever appeared in any of my newspaper stories or two books at any time in my 16-years of practicing journalism. Nevertheless, the information I gave the Star was wrong and I will be punished with the loss of my newspaper career."

Neither Freeman or Ryerson could be reached for comment this weekend. Editors in the Times and Star sports departments declined to comment on the matter Saturday. It is not known if the Star has a college graduation requirement for employees.

Freeman, 37, had been a sports reporter for the past 10 years at the Times, where he covered the NBA and NFL, according to the Associated Press. He previously worked at The Dallas Morning News, Boston Globe and The Washington Post .

Freeman's resignation came just three days after USA Today foreign correspondent and Pulitzer Prize finalist Jack Kelley quit that paper following allegations of fabricated stories, and less than a year after Jayson Blair was forced to leave The New York Times after committing a long list of deceptions, a situation that resulted in later departure of the Times' executive editor and managing editor. Kelley's resignation followed a lengthy internal investigation into allegations that he falsified stories. Although the investigation proved no evidence of wrongdoing by Kelley, he told colleagues that the situation had created a "hostile atmosphere" at the paper in which he could not continue to work.
 
Last edited:
Upvote 0
The Players - Mike Freeman

Mike still seems facinated with OSU. Here is his latest story on the Buckeyes.


Last modified Sun., November 14, 2004 - 12:34 AM
Originally created Sunday, November 14, 2004

11/14/04
Buckeyes AD presides over absurd scene - Jacksonville Times-Union FB

Buckeyes AD presides over absurd scene
By MIKE FREEMAN, Times-Union columnist

It must be nice to be a human non-stick surface, where denial is crusted onto the bones, the genetic material soaked in Teflon. It must be convenient to be a man of such stupendous arrogance, to feel that you can never admit wrongdoing. This is what it is to be in Geiger World.

Andy Geiger is the athletic director at The Ohio State University, overseeing one of the most historic football programs in history, sitting atop one scandal after another, scandals that would make any past wrongdoings at Florida or Florida State seem like minutia. There have been so many arrests, cash handouts and alleged grade fixing scams under the watch of Geiger, considered by some to be the best AD in America, the NCAA infractions people should open a branch office in Columbus.

That is why the latest Maurice Clarett saga -- Which is this, by the way? Clarett Episode One? Five? Six? I forget -- is such a national and important story. If there is any program, or man, that symbolizes why the college system has gone so completely screwy, it is the Buckeyes and Geiger.

Free cars, easy cash, easy grades, it's all there, in every major college program, from conference to conference, from sea to shining sea. Big-time college sport has fallen and it can't get up.

We don't need a CNN newsflash to tell us this. But what Ohio State has done is traverse from the absurd into the universe of the obscene. They now lead the country in running backs produced and scandals amassed. When asked what he blamed the most for current problems at the school, Murray Sperber, a former Indiana professor and current author who is a critic of big-time college sports, said in an e-mail interview: "I blame Buckeye Fever, the culture in Columbus and the state of Ohio that says, 'Them Bucks should win no matter what it takes.' I blame the Ohio media for feeding this culture, and the officials at OSU for not speaking loudly against it. They pay lip service to winning with a clean program but they never say that they would rather lose to Michigan than to the NCAA. They would lose their jobs if they did."

Sperber added, "Geiger is taking a fair amount of heat right now but, yes, it's hard to believe that he never heard anything about the behavior of the alumni and boosters. Finally, Columbus is not that large a place and everyone is focused in on the football program and especially its stars like Clarett, and so there must have been rumors about the freebies."

We should not be surprised by Clarett's claims because the shenanigans at Ohio State have been ongoing for years. In 1998, former linebacker Andy Katzenmoyer said that to avoid being ruled ineligible, he took summer classes in golf, music and AIDS awareness. (Can't you see one of the questions on his midterm: "What is a par 5?") A teammate of Katzenmoyer's told Sports Illustrated he had "some grades changed." Two years later, wide receiver Reggie Germany had a grade point average of 0.00. Geiger blamed those problems on former coach John Cooper.

No, if there is one common theme arising from the stinkin' pile of corruption, it is that Geiger, the garbage truck driver, has been the man in charge. Not Cooper. Not coach Jim Tressel. But Geiger.

The latest allegations are worse. Players now say they were taking classes called Officiating Basketball and Officiating Tennis. Tressel actually taught a class on football.

That is just the beginning. If you believe Ron Zook did not run a tight ship at Florida, then the following list of arrests, compiled by the Associated Press, make Zook look like one of the nuns from my Catholic high school:

* In October, an all-nude strip club accused running back Lydell Ross of trying to pass fake currency. He was suspended for one game. In May, two players were accused of robbery. One received probation while the other was sentenced to three years in prison.

* In November of 2003, two players were arrested for disorderly conduct. One woman reported her jaw was broken. That October, backup Louis Irizarry, previously charged with robbery, was charged and later found guilty of first-degree assault.

* In October of 2002, linebacker Fred Pagac Jr. was charged with persistent disorderly conduct. That August, defensive lineman Quinn Pitcock pleaded no contest to disorderly conduct. That same month, wide receiver Chris Vance was suspended for the team opener for an undisclosed violation of team policy. In April, linebacker Marco Cooper was charged with felony drug abuse and carrying a concealed weapon. He pleaded guilty.

In all, there have been 14 player arrests since Tressel became coach in 2001. Those are statistics that would make even Barry Switzer blush.

This past June the Buckeye hoops coach, Jim O'Brien, was fired after admitting he gave a $6,000 payout to a recruit. There were professors that changed the grades of basketball players to keep them eligible. This week O'Brien sued the university for wrongful termination.

What has been Geiger's response to all of this? What problems, he says? We're a model program, he snorts. He is see-no-evil Geiger. Andy the Blind. Andy the Innocent.

Clarett is a duplicitous, confused punk. He carries more baggage than a C-130. He is also extremely intelligent ... and I believe him. I wrote the first Clarett scandal story over a year ago while working at the New York Times. It detailed the claims of a former teaching assistant that alleged a number of academic improprieties, many of them involving Clarett. At the time, Clarett denied her claims but now, he is saying they are true. Geiger ripped her as mentally unstable. He attempted to intimidate me from running the story.

Later, after its publication, Geiger and other Ohio State officials met with a group of Times editors to complain further. Geiger claimed that I was never in Columbus, even though I spent almost two weeks there, and met one of the school's PR people on campus (The phrase thou doth protest too much applies here to Geiger).

I also saw firsthand one of the sweet $30,000 SUVs Clarett now claims were illegally given to him, parked in the driveway of Clarett's condo (I think it was a nice shade of red).

Clarett is now the one in Geiger's crosshairs. One NFL general manager said this week that during Clarett's legal battles to gain early entrance into the NFL, Geiger phoned his and other teams, and completely trashed the back. Geiger does not just shoot the messengers, he nukes them.

Geiger has survived the scandals unscathed because of an at times pusillanimous Ohio press. The ba-jillions of dollars he has raked into the athletic program also act as a sort of force field, repelling opponents. One estimate says the athletic department generated a staggering $87 million in revenue in 2002-2003 alone, tops in the nation.

Not even Geiger can huff and puff his way out of many more player arrests and alleged NCAA violations. In the Clarett case, Geiger believes that everyone -- Clarett, the tutor, the other players that have corroborated Clarett's story -- are all ax-grinding liars.

Isn't it possible? Just possible?

That they are telling the truth.

And Ohio State isn't?

mike.freemanjacksonville.com, (904) 359-4377
 
Last edited:
Upvote 0
He said ... they said - 11/16/04

11/16/04 Articles:

Earle Bruce
http://www.10tv.com/Global/story.asp?S=2563953
The NCAA won't discuss potential investigations, but Sunday night on Wall-to-Wall Sports, former OSU head coach Earl Bruce said schools like OSU have always set the highest standard for athletics and football.

"You don't turn into a crook over one day or one guy. Someone's wrong and I would bet all my money one guy by the name of Clarett is wrong. Not Ohio State University and the football program in particular," says Bruce.



Andy Geiger
http://www.10tv.com/Global/story.asp?S=2563953
Andy Geiger says he believes Clarett's latest claims will be easy to refute but declined to say if the NCAA is looking at any new allegations.

Geiger says, "I guess I can't comment in the course of the, in the middle of the investigation, but I'm pretty confident."



Jim Tressel
http://www.daytondailynews.com/localnews/content/life/daily/1116dl.html
"We have probably 78 car dealers that help Ohio State athletic programs," Tressel said. "The only thing that's made clear to them is if they see any of our student-athletes in any sport, that they're to be treated like any other customer.



Mark Shapiro
http://sports.espn.go.com/ncf/news/story?id=1924237
Mark Shapiro, executive vice president of programming and production at ESPN, said Geiger's attacks on the network "are blatantly misguided."

Shapiro said ESPN's reporting was objective and balanced.

"For anyone to accuse us of having an agenda against Ohio State is absurd," he said.
 
Last edited:
Upvote 0
Back
Top