• Follow us on Twitter @buckeyeplanet and @bp_recruiting, like us on Facebook! Enjoy a post or article, recommend it to others! BP is only as strong as its community, and we only promote by word of mouth, so share away!
  • Consider registering! Fewer and higher quality ads, no emails you don't want, access to all the forums, download game torrents, private messages, polls, Sportsbook, etc. Even if you just want to lurk, there are a lot of good reasons to register!

Game Thread Ohio State at Penn State, 10/22/16, 8:00pm ET ABC/WatchESPN

I don't recall that we have run the jet sweep at all and certainly not last night. The option on the other hand can just die and never come back. The screen into the interior with Brown was a great call but wrong player.
If they have, it's been rare.

Now last year they tried it occasionally, but the blocking was pretty uninspiring. I was hoping to see what this unit would do with much better perimeter blocking.
 
Upvote 0
I would like to see us get Samuel and/or Wilson matched up on the LB. Quick slants or crosses coming out of the slot would be great and easy on the Oline. With the way the DEs were coming up the field, I was surprised we didn't run right underneath them.
 
Upvote 0
These same flaws have been evident throughout Urban's tenure.

2012 braxton? Yep, and that was with NFL WRs and a big arm.
2013 braxton? Yep, same.
2014 barrett? Yep, save for one game, and that was with trading Brown for Thomas (who is killing it in the league) and adding Marshall.
2015 CJ/JT? Yep, save for a bowl game against an iffy ND team.
2016 barrett? Yep, although I think JT did fairly well in the pedestrian scheme yesterday.

The exception is 1 MSU game by JT and 3 star-crossed games by Cardale (two of which had very leaky downfield coverage)

Bill Greene talks about this a lot, with this being the transition between the studs that left and those that are coming. Also, outside WR recruiting and DT recruiting were the exceptions to the rule in Urban's great recruiting. That finally changed with the 2016 & 2017 classes, but those guys aren't going to win a title this year.

Terry McLaurin has been making some plays, but he wasn't a top ranked guy.

Dixon is not healthy.

Smith is not reliable (and now hurt).

Campbell is a RB learning the position. He is a prime example of the problem with this offense. Not his downfield play, but their inability to get the ball to him naturally in motion. He's ultra fast with decent size yet returns are the only place he can impact the game.

Samuel is a RB. A big mismatch but a RB nonetheless. That was evident in the drop in Madison.

Wilson has really matured and played through regular injury. He's still an h-back but one they can use somewhat.

Brown is a possession guy and red zone WR with a QB that throws the fade route poorly. He even struggled to loft the pass for the enormously long Victor a few weeks ago.

Mack hit the wall a bit. I hope he plays more.

Victor is a bean pole. He'll be a monster some day, but for now, he needs a year of S&C. He also doesn't provide a great downfield threat with a QB that throws downfield poorly. That's one big part that's lost in all of this.

Braxton was inconsistent but could fire lasers deep, albeit sometime late. Cardale was a flamethrower but inconsistent. JT is mediocre to poor on most downfield throws. Now that he's finally figured out how to throw a few good ones per game, they have some pretty mediocre high pointers receiving them. Clark has not tracked the deep ball well throughout his career. Dontre has improved but isn't great. Samuel is a great weapon but again, not consistent downfield.


They have too much talent to not be competent in the passing game. That said, I think they lack the talent that Herman had in terms of high level WR talent (since Gibson is ineligible and the best talent is either brand new or still in HS).
Agree on all counts. Required reading for anyone assessing the situation. Thanks Jwins.
 
Upvote 0
Ketchup might help. I personally prefer Hunt's Natural--no corn syrup. But, to each his/her own.

Eat+Crow.jpg
NOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO

I KNEW THAT GUY!
 
Upvote 0
NOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO

I KNEW THAT GUY!

darth-vader-no.jpg
 
Upvote 0
These same flaws have been evident throughout Urban's tenure.

2012 braxton? Yep, and that was with NFL WRs and a big arm.
2013 braxton? Yep, same.
2014 barrett? Yep, save for one game, and that was with trading Brown for Thomas (who is killing it in the league) and adding Marshall.
2015 CJ/JT? Yep, save for a bowl game against an iffy ND team.
2016 barrett? Yep, although I think JT did fairly well in the pedestrian scheme yesterday.

The exception is 1 MSU game by JT and 3 star-crossed games by Cardale (two of which had very leaky downfield coverage)

Bill Greene talks about this a lot, with this being the transition between the studs that left and those that are coming. Also, outside WR recruiting and DT recruiting were the exceptions to the rule in Urban's great recruiting. That finally changed with the 2016 & 2017 classes, but those guys aren't going to win a title this year.

Terry McLaurin has been making some plays, but he wasn't a top ranked guy.

Dixon is not healthy.

Smith is not reliable (and now hurt).

Campbell is a RB learning the position. He is a prime example of the problem with this offense. Not his downfield play, but their inability to get the ball to him naturally in motion. He's ultra fast with decent size yet returns are the only place he can impact the game.

Samuel is a RB. A big mismatch but a RB nonetheless. That was evident in the drop in Madison.

Wilson has really matured and played through regular injury. He's still an h-back but one they can use somewhat.

Brown is a possession guy and red zone WR with a QB that throws the fade route poorly. He even struggled to loft the pass for the enormously long Victor a few weeks ago.

Mack hit the wall a bit. I hope he plays more.

Victor is a bean pole. He'll be a monster some day, but for now, he needs a year of S&C. He also doesn't provide a great downfield threat with a QB that throws downfield poorly. That's one big part that's lost in all of this.

Braxton was inconsistent but could fire lasers deep, albeit sometime late. Cardale was a flamethrower but inconsistent. JT is mediocre to poor on most downfield throws. Now that he's finally figured out how to throw a few good ones per game, they have some pretty mediocre high pointers receiving them. Clark has not tracked the deep ball well throughout his career. Dontre has improved but isn't great. Samuel is a great weapon but again, not consistent downfield.


They have too much talent to not be competent in the passing game. That said, I think they lack the talent that Herman had in terms of high level WR talent (since Gibson is ineligible and the best talent is either brand new or still in HS).

Great post. So this is just a reoccurring weakness in Meyer's coaching that can only be cured if he makes a great hire and is willing to give up some control?

Plus better outside talent too.
 
Upvote 0
The jet sweep is fine if they actually use it well to keep teams honest and from collapsing on it. The option, on the other hand...if they absolutely must continue to use it, then run it to the far side of the field! I don't understand why they always seem to want to run it to the near side when it takes away space for the player getting the pitch to create missed tackles and lanes keep getting clogged with blockers and defenders. Or set it up with a reverse if you must run plays to the near side.
 
Upvote 0
The jet sweep is fine if they actually use it well to keep teams honest and from collapsing on it. The option, on the other hand...if they absolutely must continue to use it, then run it to the far side of the field! I don't understand why they always seem to want to run it to the near side when it takes away space for the player getting the pitch to create missed tackles and lanes keep getting clogged with blockers and defenders. Or set it up with a reverse if you must run plays to the near side.

I would get the short side is technically a numbers or power advantage vs the wide side, depending on coverage. But everyone is correct that those numbers disappear rather quickly with LBs and Safties crashing. Unfortunately, Curtis Samuel and to a lesser extent Dontre are the only ones that have shown they can do anything after catching the ball. Again, you can either expect WRs get open or scheme them open. You have to challenge the defense rather than slamming your playmakers into a mass of bodies or a spying safety.
 
Upvote 0
That was tough to watch - at least the 4th qtr. A few thoughts:

1) I hate losing to Penn State, especially if it has any chance of jump starting that program. Would be happy if they hovered around 6-6 for the rest of their existence. That sentiment has everything to do with their fans and nothing to do with their team/players. I really admired how hard those guys played and how much heart they showed. We could have used a little more of that.

2) Momentum is a powerful thing in sports. When you got it, you can almost do no wrong. Even your mistakes work out. When it's going against you, nothing works out. That game was weird in that it felt like the Bucks were in control of the game thru 3 qtrs, and was on the verge of blowing it out with one or two explosive plays. Then the 4th came around and Big Mo shifted. You see that in basketball more where a team controls the game for a half or so, and then Mo shifts dramatically, but it's rarer in football.

3) I have quite a few buddies who focus on the horseshit horse collar call and the not called PI. I keep telling them they sound like PSU fans. That did not lose the game. Poor execution at crucial times in all 3 phases lost the game. Ohio State had plenty of opportunities to overcome their own mistakes, the refs' mistakes, and the good play of PSU. They didn't. The one silver lining is that it may quell the conspiracy theory popular to our east that the B1G has the refs favor Ohio State and scUM over PSU - but I doubt it.

4) I have a theory about what one of the weaknesses is of the Urban offense, and I believe it is wet and windy weather. I seem to recall a loss last year played in something similar to a hurricane. It grounds their passing game, and the coaches seem to believe that they can switch gears and play a slog game. But teams have identities that translate to what they do best and feel best about doing, and when the game is played in a 12 x 52 yard box, that's not what they are designed to do. That kind of weather can do that all by itself, and basically does half the work for the defense trying to stop them. Then Ohio State has to play left handed - a style they don't like - and the players seem to get frustrated. Simultaneously, it seems to help build confidence and momentum for the other guys. This is accentuated by the fact that OSU hasn't been able to stretch the field vertically for several games now and get their offense working in a 40-50 x 52 yard box, which is where they are most explosive and effective. But I think Urban needs to figure out a way to have the offense succeed in wet/windy conditions because I've lived in the Midwest a long time, and we tend to get that this time of year.

5) Ohio State is fine - in the sense that all of their goals are intact. The margin for error is gone, but this was the time to lose if they were going to. Better at PSU than in EL or any time in Nov. They lost to Sparty last year, refocused, fixed some issues, got their heads right, and went on to destroy scUM and ND. If they respond the same way, all is well.
 
Upvote 0
...To the playoffs?? 8D

Shh, let me just enjoy the fact that the possibility is still there. I'll take this feeling over last year's MSU fiasco.

Anything could happen. Suppose we'll find out Saturday what the plan is from here on out.
Yeah I'm not nearly as upset as I was last year. This was a bad loss no doubt, but like jaxbuck said, it was more of a combination of flukes that caused us to lose. To this day I believe someone was paid off in that Michigan State game. It's still the only logical explanation.
 
Upvote 0
Back
Top